StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

The House of Lords Lynn - Case Study Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
The House of Lords Lynn

The question then arises what type of conduct will be sufficient to infer a common intention to share ownership Lord Bridge appears to suggest in Lloyds that indirect contributions are insufficient to found a beneficial interest under an implied constructive trust too:
"In this situation direct contributions to the purchase price by the partner who is not the legal owner, whether initially or by payment of mortgage instalments, will readily justify the inference necessary for the creation of a constructive trust. But, as I read the authorities, it is at least extremely doubtful whether anything less will do."
It is not clear to which cases Lord Bridges is referring in his final sentence. There are high profile cases where it is argued that indirect contributions should be regarded as evidence that an agreement for a beneficial interest should be inferred: Gissing v Gissing [1971] AC 886 and Burns v Burns [1984] 1 Ch 317. The line of reasoning in these cases suggest that it is not just the making of the indirect contribution; there must also have been the aim of assisting in the purchase of the property and/or that without that contribution the mortgage would not have been paid.
"Contributions are not limited to those made directly in part payment of the price of the property or to those made at the time when the property is conveyed into the name of one of the spouses. For instance there can be a contribution if by arrangement between the spouses one of them by payment of the household expenses enables the other to pay the mortgage instalments."

Given the importance of precedent in English law it is submitted that Lord Bridge's statement could not have been meant to overrule such authorities. Clearly there is established authority that in appropriate circumstances the court may infer that the parties' common intention was to give the claimant an interest by way of indirect contributions.

We are told that 'Mike would not have been able to meet the mortgage payments out of his own salary' had Lynn not worked part-time to discharge the other household expenses. There is clearly a link between the mortgage payments and the expenses undertaken by Lynn. It is therefore submitted that Le Foe v Le Foe [2001] 2 FLR 970 is consistent with Lord Bridge's speech in Lloyds and in fact is a direct application of precedent in this area. As Mr Mostyn QC himself said:

"I believe that a fair reading of [May LJ's judgement in Burns v. Burns [1984] FLR 216] is that such a state of affairs should suffice to enable the necessary inference to be drawn. Otherwise these cases would be decided by reference to mere accidents of fortune, being the arbitrary allocation of financial responsibility as between the parties."

Le Foe is an illustration of such contributions and their effects, where the court construed the Lloyds' principles and concluded that the claimant will be entitled to a beneficial interest by way of indirect contributions in exceptional circumstances. It is therefore submitted that at first instance and appeal Lord Bridge's remarks have been misinterpreted and that Lynn does indeed have a beneficial interest in the property via an implied constructive trust.

Waite LJ's judgement in Midland Bank plc v Cooke [1995] 4 All ER 562 goes to quantification of the ...Show more

Summary

In order to successfully appeal to the House of Lords Lynn will need to establish that there is a point of law which their Lordships are required to clarify. We would argue that the High Court and Court of Appeal erred on the first point in their judgement with regard to the status of Lynn's indirect contribution to the acquisition of the property…
Author : philll
The House of Lords Lynn essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the case study on your topic
"The House of Lords Lynn"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

House of Tata
Creation of a group brand While discussing the relevance associated with the creation of a single group based brand for the Tata, it is of high importance to focus on the business scenario that existed during that particular time period. The scenario of India before the liberalization of the economy of India was filled with challenges for the business communities and enterprises.
8 pages (2000 words) Case Study
House of Tata
These incorporated other companies that were not using the Tata brand name in their products. The companies could use the reputation of Tata in raising money for global and domestic markets, as well as accessing the financial and managerial support from the group.
6 pages (1500 words) Case Study
Breeze House
This is caused by the two factors. First, the revenues generated by the company through its sales will only be accounted after two months of service completion. Second, the accounts receivables of the company is out of control with 10% of sales incurred as bad debts and almost 74% of the outstanding debts have been due for 90 days or more.
10 pages (2500 words) Case Study
House Buliding Industry
The industry has been working in closely with other related industries like the financial institutions and insurance companies. There are many players in the industry and the recent developments have seen the rise of home building and home selling companies which originally existed as one.
10 pages (2500 words) Case Study
Resulting and Constructive Trust in Equity & Trust
In 1991, Lynn gave birth to their first child, changed her surname to Mike's and held herself out to their friends and family as his wife. A second child was born in1995. Over the years, the mortgage payments were always paid out of Mike's salary, whilst Lynn paid all the food bills and out goings on the house (I.e., council tax, water rates, gas, electricity and telephone charges) out if her own income as part-time secretary.
7 pages (1750 words) Case Study
Potter House
Since B was only 16 years old when the property is purchased, the property may be held on trust. As such, until B reaches the age of majority i.e. 18 years old, his property is held on trust by the other owners. Although B is not the legal owner of the property but B has the beneficial right to the property i.e.
4 pages (1000 words) Case Study
House of Tata
220 billion.2 Ratan Tata, chairman since 1991 of the group holding company. Jamsetji Tata planted the roots of the Tata Group by establishing a single textile mill in 1874. Throughout his expansive career, he never lost sight of his goal to encourage India's industrial and intellectual development.
5 pages (1250 words) Case Study
Carter/Tucker House
Its form is that of a glass box that is comprised of cedar panels that are slender in size. Considering the skin of the building, it is noted that
2 pages (500 words) Case Study
Lynn Tilton's Leadership Helps Turn Around Failing Companies
However, Tilton’s level of interpersonal competence is low because she lacks the ability to demonstrate caring and empathy. Considering her traits of character, Tilton will certainly be rated
4 pages (1000 words) Case Study
Research about social Impact of Flooding, Building regulation of flooding at King's Lynn in the UK
However, the harbour of this port plus the river below the Denver sluice was highly affected by silting. The silting problem was attributed to the effects of the sluice. This silting was primarily caused by deposition of sand caused by the incoming tides (Gardine &
2 pages (500 words) Case Study
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation