Discussion questions (Essay)

College
Essay
Miscellaneous
Pages 2 (502 words)
Download 0
The process of appointment of Supreme Court states that 'the President will nominate and by and with the advice and consent of the Senate, shall appoint Judges of Supreme Court' (Rutkus 2005). The above statement shows that the appointment process of Supreme Court Judges is purely based on the President's nomination…

Introduction

Of course, the qualification, experience, and decision making capabilities are also analyzed and form an integral part of the appointment process.
Almost everyone would maintain that the appointment of Supreme Court Judges should not be made using the above criteria as this violates the principles of independence. A Supreme Court is the highest judicial bench in the country and as such, the decisions should be taken on merit; without prejudice to any person, belief, or religion; and after careful analysis of all evidences. However, if the appointments are made based on personal preferences, the decisions may be skewed towards the state and according to the desires of President's office. This creates the controversy that Supreme Court is not as independent as one would like it to be.
'''The biggest damn fool mistake I ever made,'' Dwight D. Eisenhower said of his appointment of Chief Justice Earl Warren, who discomfited him with the Brown v. Board of Education ruling ordering desegregation of public schools, and other liberal opinions. Harry S. Truman was even more scathing about Justice Tom C. Clark, a Truman appointee who voted against his 1952 seizure of the steel industry to avert a strike.' (Purdum 2005).
This shows that the Court decisions are not always biased in favor of ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related papers

Discussion Questions( corporate governance& ethics)
Businesses subscribing to ethical behavior tend to gain tangible rewards in the sense that ethics not only portray any brand as being clean and above board, but they also streamline and organize the internal functioning of the businesses. Considering the contemporary business environment defined by a cut throat competition, ethical credentials endow businesses with sound and reliable USPs that…
Critical Thinking Discussion Questions
Then the decision made is clear and understood. This is not true when decision making includes people of differing backgrounds, experiences, and ethics.…
Discussion Questions 95
Defined in very general terms, policy beliefs are just statements that reveal what an organization or person believes in, and why the organization or person is currently advocating a particular policy position. Being relatively straightforward, policy beliefs play a key role in the policy process. Advocacy groups, concerned citizens, policymakers, and other organized lobbying entities use their…
Discussion Questions( corporate governance& ethics) Essay
Such a leadership style inevitably has a positive impact on the people.…
Discussion questions (Essay)
Of course, the qualification, experience, and decision making capabilities are also analyzed and form an integral part of the appointment process.…
The American Experience Discussion Questions
This legitimacy has been questioned over the years by various leaders such as Nelson Mandela who was quoted as saying "if there is a country that has committed unspeakable atrocities in the world, it is the United States of America (Nagasaki and Hiroshima)"(Daily News, NY). The view of the role the U.S. has taken on has changed from positive to negative. The United States recently has taken on the…
Discussion Questions Essay
In this way, firms of different sizes could be compared on an equal footing. For example, COGS of firm A may be greater than that of firm B. But its sales may be higher too.…