StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Leaders are born and not made critically discuss - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
Leaders are born and not made critically discuss

Today's dynamic environment requires leaders to be flexible enough to drive change in the organization.
The paper elaborates and critically discusses the different leadership approaches and theories. It critically analyzes the statement that "leaders are born not made" in the light of the views of different authors on various theories.
In the early twenty century, it was considered that the leaders are born and cannot be made. It was assumed that there must be three qualities in every leader and on the basis of these qualities the leaders can be judged. Personality, physicality and mentality were the elements that were found mandatory to be a leader. It was also thought that the organizations having an ability to recognize great leaders would touch the pinnacle of success (Horner 1997). According to this view, the leaders are born and these qualities cannot be developed. Without the natural capabilities and abilities no one could become a leader. These leadership qualities are the gift of nature that can be given to any one regardless of sex, nationality and origin.
Horner suggests that a number of researches have been carried out to distinguish the qualities of a leader but so far no great output has been achieved. The author says that there may be several situational and environmental factors that add up to a leader's effectiveness (1997). According to a famous Michigan and Ohio State leadership study in the context of an organization, consideration and initiation as two most important factors. The same was proved with the research carried out at other several colleges and universities. In the presence of this research, it can be said that leadership qualities are not necessarily inborn but it can also be grown in the employees (Horner 1997). Leadership is something keenly related to the behaviors that can be taught to the employees. The employees are not necessarily born with leadership qualities but these are the qualities that can rise up in the employees. If the employees are motivated and trained in the manner there is no reason why the maximum output is not achieved and they will surely be proved themselves as the great prospective leaders.

Some researchers have moved forward with their research to discover what leadership behaviours are and how the behaviours of leader can be distinguished from their subordinates. In the light of those behaviours the art of leadership could be taught. Such researches focus on both people oriented and task oriented actions of behaviour. (Horner 1997). This behaviour can be learned instead of considering that these are inborn factors.

There are several leadership theories that elaborate leadership behaviours, traits and qualities. These theories explain the different aspect of leadership and qualities of a good leader or weather these can only be the inborn qualities or they can be taught as well. The first theory is the great man theory that says that the "leaders are born and not made". According to the theory, the great leadership abilities are inherited and can not be taught to any one. Further only the great man can lead and the subordinates are made to obey these great men (Roberts 1994). The great leaders show up when there is a great need of them. The main idea of the Great man theory was the recognition of the great people as natural born leaders. The theory further says that the history has been formed by great leaders. Mostly the people of ...Show more


Leaders are the people who have the vision to put company in the right direction. Different authors have various views about leadership. Some say these qualities are inborn and granted as the gift of nature [e.g. Horner 1997 and Kotter 1998]. There are authors [e.g…
Author : aemard
Leaders are born and not made critically discuss essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Leaders are born and not made critically discuss"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Are Leaders Born or Made
Is it only about inspiring others? Does the much hyped up political or religious leaders are the only kind or there exist many leaders around us in all strata’s of life varying in magnitude. If true than what are the different types of leadership. This paper aims to offer a dynamic theory on leadership development and will study literature examining trait(s) which are argued as genetic, whilst counterargument with the notion that leaders are a lot more made than they are born (Zenger et al 2007, page 5).
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Are Leaders Born or Made
Research (David Giber, Linkage Inc, 2009) has proved that if we tie leadership development to business strategy and need of the business it results in excellent organizational growth. The pressure to integrate leadership development activities and initiatives in the overall strategic objective of the business is the most important and overarching trend in recent history.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Criminals are made, not born. Critically discuss this statement
When one thinks about these theories, one might ask why one would think there are a biological determinism, and sociological determinism. Many think people commit crimes because of sociological determinism, and biological determinism. Many think one needs to have the biological determinism, and sociological determinism together before one would commit a crime.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Management and Leadership development (Are leaders born or made)
Use the other essay provided as an example of how to structure. There doesn’t need to be much written to restructure, just reword some things so it doesn’t sound like a story, (more third person) Create a model that suggests that Leaders are Developed more than they are Born and apply this to the real life working environment.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Are Leaders Born Or Made How Do We Identify Leaders Do We Need Leaders In This Current Economic Climate
Leadership comes with specific qualities, insight, observation, and a clean character. In contemporary organisations, where leadership demands supreme importance, effectiveness is achieved through management principles in addition to leaders’ qualities.
16 pages (4000 words) Essay
Critically discuss the following statement: 'Effective leaders are born, not made.'
Knowing the points will support to grow effective leaders for corporation. It looks like there is just a single thing that one requires to essentially be born with, in order to be a leader afterwards in time. That is brainpower. A leader has to be sufficiently
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Transformational corporate leaders are born not made
It was with his book about political leadership in 1978 that he presented in front of the world two concepts of transactional and transformational leadership. While drawing a line between these two modes of leadership,
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Are leaders born or made
Rational beliefs about employees’ or followers’ inherent leadership attributes are also commonly used by organizations when
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Do you believe the greatest leaders are born, not made
Born leaders are the leaders who are able to lead and conduct the community without any formal training or education and possess natural leadership skills. A born leader must have some of the following traits to be able to lead the
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Leaders are born, not made Drucker p. Critically discuss this view of leadership and using one or more of the theories of leadership such as kotter and adair, indicate how leadership skills may be developed or enhanced to improve organization performance
Many people will argue that way. Some researchers have argued that leadership is a trait or behaviour. Leadership is a calling that comes from within, and cannot be forced. Leadership cannot be created, taught, learned, or promoted, just like Drucker argued that leaders
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Contact Us