StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Why, despite Seemingly Copious Sources, Is Our Knowledge of Celtic Mythology So Fragmentary - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
Why, despite Seemingly Copious Sources, Is Our Knowledge of Celtic Mythology So Fragmentary

The Romans considered their Celtic neighbours to be barbarians, but their observations provide much of our body evidence in the study of  mythology, in particular Julius Caesar, Lucan and Posidonius (Brezina, 2008, p.11). The two cultures co-existed but often clashed, as they were built on entirely different beliefs, traditions and values (Aldhouse-Green, 1998, p. 8). Furthermore, their relationship was also marked by conflict; the Romans successfully conquered Celtic Britain in the first-century, only to have their capital sacked by the Celts two centuries later (Brezina, 2008, p. 7). Consequently, historians such as Aldhouse-Green, have warned of the problems of using Roman sources as evidence. She argues that that there is a real danger of "bias distortion, misunderstanding and admission" which will affect the authenticity and usefulness of their opinions and observations. Classical writers may well have sensationalised  or deliberately selected aspects of Celtic behaviour and ideas to create the image of an "uncivilised" race, and thus add to their own sense of superiority (1998. p. 8). The Romans may well have “singled out” or exaggerated particular Celtic ideas and beliefs which seemed alien to them. Brezina has commented that they offer “confused” and “fragmentary” accounts of the gods especially as they seemed very strange to the Romans ( 2008, p. 11). Their accounts also present difficulties for the historian because they employed Roman terminology when describing Celtic religion. This further compounds the difficulties of interpretation (Maier, 1997, p. 24). The second type of source to be discussed come from the Middle Ages and were compiled throughout Britain. Once again, the historian is immediately confronted with a problem which potentially affects their reliability and authenticity; the influence of Christianity (Aldhouse-Green, 1998, p. 9). Maier argues that this influence means that such accounts are not a true reflection of “pre-Christian mythology” and should actually be viewed as a “creative interpretation”. To be able to use them correctly also requires an excellent knowledge of Medieval Welsh and Irish sources, and a constant reviewing when new material is discovered. ...Show more

Summary

The essay "Why, despite Seemingly Copious Sources, Is Our Knowledge of Celtic Mythology So Fragmentary?" has attempted to show the problematic nature of the different sources used by historians in the study of Celtic mythology. It is these problems of authenticity, reliability and bias, inherent in each source, which make our knowledge fragmentary…
Author : ywindler
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Why, despite Seemingly Copious Sources, Is Our Knowledge of Celtic Mythology So Fragmentary"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Why is it that despite our affluence, happiness is so elusive in the industrialised world
Why is it that despite our affluence, happiness is so elusive in the industrialized world? Happiness may be manifested by the predominance of positive emotions and is chiefly cognitive. Happiness is a state of mind demystified by an enduring enjoyment of life out of consciousness of the purpose and meaning of life.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Mythology
Perhaps it stands to be truer of the times in which the Classical myths came into existence, as the progenitors of these myths having no access to the modern scientific knowledge were may be more prone to humanize and deify the salient yet mysterious aspects of nature, human attributes and phenomenon that defied human understanding.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Mythology
One way of doing this is through the formation of a national emblem and a national flag. The value of a national emblem and a national flag is highly important because it represents the image of the nation. It makes a bold statement that a particular nation is independent and steadfast to partake their role in the international scene.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Why the Culture of Supernatural is So Popular in Our Society
Apparently, as the technological revolution commenced at a point in the past, technology itself serves a chief ground why the culture of supernatural has well-embedded on our society besides the influence of primordial need, science, and the constant traditional effort of propagating random stories about vampires and the like.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Celtic Rock
On the other coast of America, the seeds for Flogging Molly was being sown. Most date the band to 1997 with the release of “Alive Behind the Green Door”(a live album recorded in the bar where the band started)
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Knowledge can be gained from books and scientific observation. What are some other important sources of knowledge andd why are they valuable
Apart from these two, there are other knowledge sources which are just as important. These sources of knowledge are discussed below. This is one of the most basic sources of information. When a child is
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Why has the Mafia been able to survive for so long, despite enormous pressure from law enforcement
To this end, the infamous mafia known as the American mafia or Cosa Notra is regarded as an extension of the Sicilian mafia owing to its members drawn from the Italian American society. A
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Why is there so much violence in our culture
Though history is replete with the presence of violence in every society of the world since the known records of human life on the face of the earth; somehow,
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Define hero. Why does our society insist upon elevating people to the rank of hero Is John Bradley a hero despite his insistence that he was not
‘Flags of our fathers’ is a book written by James Bradley with Ron Powers. The book tells about the story of the five US marines and one US Navy Corpsman who got photographed by Joe Rosenthal raising the American flag at Iwo Jima. Iwo Jima represented a
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Use your critical thinking skills to evaluate the article Why Does Our Collective Empathy So Often Fail to Manifest in Our Treatment of Refugees by Shami Chakrabarti
Britain’s nationals are yet to treat refuges in a fair manner, this is evident by the numerous cases reported of refugees been harassed, and that
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Contact Us