Is Your State Governed by Daubert or Frye - Term Paper Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Is Your State Governed by Daubert or Frye

by using experience and common sense, professional witness give conclusions on the basis of the knowledge and practices beyond the average judge’s comprehension (Suzanne, 1996). Consequently, statement by unpoliced professional witness can possibly have a biased effect on the judge, who might tend to be more inclined to believing that that the statement is exclusively based on the expert status of the witness. How can the trial jury be in a position of determining whether the professional is just speculating, or even whether the proof on which the professional is basing their statement is adequate to support the ruling? Certainly, the lay witness is prevented from speculation by the jury and can direct rulings when there is adequate evidence in support of a finding. Then is the screening of professional witness by a judge different from this practice? This is a question that poses weighty issues regarding the nature of the role of the judges. In order to be in a position of making an informed judgment concerning whether to admit a professional, the jury would appear to require at least a modicum of professionalism in the field of witness.
In Robinson, which involved a professional testimony regarding whether a DuPont fertilizer harmed the pecan trees of Robinsons, we find that the Supreme Court of Texas maintained that the Texas’ Civil Evidence Laws not only need a professional witness to be qualified, but also to offer statement that is relevant and also on the basis of a credible foundation. Nevertheless, in so doing, Robinson sufficiently adopted the standard of Daubert. The main difference in the case of Robinson was the fact that the Supreme Court of Texas had never adopted the ‘general acceptance’ standard of Frye that was particularly dismissed in Daubert, but instead had used an examination of whether the professional testimony ‘helped the fact’s trier’ under the 702 Rule. However, the Supreme Court of Texas perceived the credibility and ...
Download paper


From the comparisons of fiber to psychiatric examinations and economic projections, the scope of given proficiency or expertise covers the span of the knowledge of human beings. Rarely any…
Author : hudsonkali



Related Essays

Modern State
The concept and framework of the modern state is difficult to define because it involves a combination of historical, economic, political and cultural factors. Historical mythologies and memories are shared, traditional routes of pilgrimage have united the nations of the continent in common religious bonds throughout history, and now they all share the same market (Morphet 517). It is possible to single out the following distinctive features of the modern state: high level of nationalism and multiculturalism, liberal institutions and importance of national culture, integrity and cooperation on...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
To what extent is musical taste governed by society?
Through historical study of music, it is clear that music was thought as endanger to societal moral standards of Europe. However later it was realised that music also upholds a religious dimension and quality music has the ability to provoke suppressed religious feelings (McLeod, 1996, p. 17).In this paper, we would analyse music as a magnum opus in the context of historical, cultural and educational significance. How its evolution as an art, closely connected with various trends of our Western civilization Music in different stages has not only permitted but has enforced the application of...
12 pages (3012 words) Essay
State your reasons for wishing to pursue the course for which you have applied
I have worked as a sales assistant and as an administrative assistant which I feel will make a good foundation to move into a larger type of work in this area. I would enjoy working in a financial institution in Western Europe so I want to prepare myself as much as possible to pursue my dream in that area.
3 pages (753 words) Admission/Application Essay
state capitalism
For some, it is very improbable that this period has adequate technical merit. There is no short and so straightforward delineation of the notion is usually acknowledged, for the straightforward cause that communal idea in general, in a sense, this is a try to work out the source, environment and destiny of capitalism (Bremmer 240). Therefore, what should of necessity highly selective representation. Its aim is directed at some centered issue of outlook on capitalism as humanity, as annals and as a presence.
10 pages (2510 words) Essay
determine whether compensation and overtime applies to exempt and non-exempt security personnel in your state.
in our numbers lately and we need to play catch up.” “Will we be receiving overtime?” Bob the employee inquires, though he already knows the response. “Good one, that’s why we moved you to salary remember?” Joe chuckles as he walks back to his office. Fairness, in workers time and effort, versus pay has long been a minefield for dispute in the workplace. Typically speaking the worker tends to feel overworked and underpaid, and the owner tends to feel the employee is underworked and overpaid. Over the years lawsuits on compensation and overtime have arisen many times, and the...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
comparing and contrasting the Frye standard, [Frye vs. United States (293 F. 1013 (DC Cir 1923)], with the Daubert standard [Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals (509 U.S. 579 (1993)
s called “Fyre in drag.” Problems have come up with this standard, due to the fact that it has led to eyebrows being raised regarding the vitality of the standard and on its flexibility to be able to adjust to different situations and fresh and new scientific matters, where "general" or "widespread" approval is not gathered. Conversely, whether fresh or new, supposedly scientific matters are issues of significance to the court have been quizzed. As a substitute to this standard, many law courts apply Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence, as the basis for professional testimony and...
10 pages (2510 words) Term Paper
Assess the state of learning and development in your chosen organisation
It is essential to note that workers must have qualities to adopt any kind of environment in addition to enhancing their skills. Through the specialized training provided by learning and development (L&D) as well as proper guidance, employee’s performance is significantly achieved. In this regard, there is need for managers to be thoroughly experienced in executing development strategies. While learning is a continuous process that aims at shaping up the skills that are hidden within an employee, development is a process that is focused at growing personal skills in order to rise the degree...
10 pages (2510 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!