A Soldiers Story Critique - Essay Example

The Joy Luck Club (1993) was directed by Wayne Wang, who had based the film on a novel written by writer Amy Tan who also did the screenplay The genre of the movie is romance interspersed with drama. The story revolves around the lives of four Chinese women who were born in America while their respective mothers had been born in feudal China. These women go on a quest to explore their past and try to understand it better and make their lives more meaningful and happy.

Saving Face is a popular movie written and directed by Alice Wu. The genre of the movie revolves around romance and drama interspersed with comedy and has a very interesting tagline that says, “A romantic comedy about right, wrong and everything in between”. It is a different kind of movie and not the run-of-the-mill kind. The story is based on the lesbianism of Asian women who speak the Chinese language occasionally. It is a touching story that plays upon the emotions and feelings of its audience. 

A Soldier’s Story deals with ethical issues of race and class that existed in the USA over sixty years ago. The murdered victim was a Black and this case is investigated by another Black military lawyer who was sent from Washington. Captain Davenport Battles amidst prejudice and deceit while in charge of uncooperative Black troops. Investigations proved that the dead soldier was very unpopular. There are a lot of ups and downs in the movie involving issues of color, caste, and background which adds spice to the situation, but despite the many negative forces acting against him, Captain Davenport pursues his mission of finding out the exact murderer of Sergeant Waters.

The Joy Luck Club (1993) is a film that is deeply immersed in ethical issues of caste and class of the important characters that are shown against an American background. Four young Chinese women born in America face racial discrimination and therefore embark on an important search for their identity to give them a better understanding to analyze the strained and difficult relationships shared presently between the respective mothers and their daughters. The movie is infused with a lot of pain and emotion as the characters try to grapple with their feelings by making sense of them. The eventful search that they undertake helps to guide these feelings and solve the many mysteries they had faced. The film is considered to be a Classic because the stories of each of these women are not only heartwarming but would also make the audience cry and laugh.

“Saving Face” is a very popular film that reached a wider audience and even though the movie dealt with such an ethical and sensitive issue as ‘lesbianism’ involving Asian women, it was very well appreciated by its audience. The story revolves around a brilliant surgeon Wil who is a Chinese American lesbian based in Manhattan. Wil is surprised by Ma who is a widow of 48 years, who gets banished from Flushing, Queens when her father found out that she was pregnant. The story of Ma touches the heart and personal life of Wil, who goes out of her way to get a suitable Chinese bachelor to marry Ma since only then she could return to her own country Flushing because of the promise made by her grandfather.

According to me, the film that deals the best with ethical issues of race and segregation is A Soldier’s Story. The story that is narrated through the lens of director Norman Jewison brings forward many ethical issues in a very powerful manner, to make its audience sit up and take notice of the injustice that is portrayed through its actors. What touched me most about this film was the element of ethics that was brought out most sensitively.

The film is pitched against the background of WWII and centers around the murder of a black non-commissioned officer belonging to a black army regiment consisting of white officers. What makes the film even more sensitive is that another black officer is commissioned to solve the mystery surrounding the murder. The film reeks of deep ethical issues of caste, creed, color, and segregation that the officer has to endure before he solves the mystery that shrouds the murder. The film is an extremely powerful thriller that is seeped in drama against a historical backdrop. The movie tends to carry its audience towards identifying with the black officer thereby blurring the line of the social divide. According to me, this is one of the best movies that deal with sensitive ethical issues of racism and segregation.