StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Response Paper to McCloskey's article - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Response Paper to McCloskey's article

He goes ahead to suggest that due to lack of proof the notion of Gods existence should be dismissed altogether. Moreover, looking keenly at the arguments he puts across it lacks substance, one of those is existence of evil, which he says it is a proof God does not exist. This kind of argument lacks merit because one can say that if presence of evil things is a proof of Gods non-existence, what about the existence of the good and what it proofs. The article has not answered this query. McCloskey believes that the cosmological argument was an argument from the existence of the world. McCloskey also states that believing in an uncaused first origin of the universe is issues because nothing about our universe leads us to that believe. However, many of us may disagree with this because we believe that God is the fundamental factor of the origin of the universe. Furthermore, scholars and philosophers term that the universe is contingent; therefore, the universe requires a necessary being to acts as an ultimate cause. Finally, this necessary being is God.His article represents his own thinking and that of atheism but does not proof anything. In his article, he puts emphasis on the point that evident proofs of nature cannot adequately elucidate the existence of God. ...
He seems to be comfortable with naturalistic ideas. McCloskey points out these objections against the cosmological argument stating that the fact that the world is real is enough evidence not to believe in such a higher being as God, but Evans and Manis puts forward the following argument in response. They say that for a contingent being to exist then there must be a necessary being that causes the contingent being to exist contingent beings exist, therefore if we are the contingent beings then God must be the Necessary being. The only fault in this response is that they do not have evidence to proof their argument (Evans and Manis, 2009).. They response to the issues raised by Mccloskey to their arguments by pointing out that atheist assertion that the universe has always survived. Manis and Evans counter by stating their approach is enough for such a challenge since they do not make any suggestion as to the age of the universe. The other issue raised by Mccloskey is that if everything has a cause, then God must have a cause as well but Manis and Evans counters this by saying that God is not a contingent being, therefore His origin cannot be known and it is unnecessary to know and that is why He is God. The main challenge to this is naturalism, this is because naturalists hold a notion that things exists at natures will and have no cause but on the same breath they cannot explain why beings exist. McCloskey points out that cosmological argument by saying that he does not sanction us to assume an all-mighty, all-perfect, all-powerful uncaused being which causes other beings. Evans and Manis accepts that this is debatable, They further note that even if the argument is held as ...Show more

Summary

Name Institution Course Date McCloskey is both critical of the conventional arguments for God’s existence and offers the crisis of evil as a cause why one should not believe in God. The issue of the existence of God has been subject to major arguments through time between people who believe God exists and those who dispute that fact…
Author : albina27
Response Paper to McCloskeys article essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Response Paper to McCloskey's article"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Response to McCloskey's Article On Being an Atheist
One philosopher, theorist, or thinker comes up with an argument only to be contested by other lines of thought. McCloskey is perhaps one of the philosophers who have given the issue of existence of God a deep thought. His arguments on the article “On Being an Atheist” present a wide dimension of thought, discussion, and critique.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Response Paper
Nevertheless, as long as one uses a different basis for his belief, then he can never possibly argue against someone who is arguing from a different context. The theists argue from one point of view while the atheists argue from a different one. Nevertheless, if one disregards the supernatural and if one uses as his basis only what man knows and what he can possibly know, then most of McCloskey’s arguments that there is no God are logically sound and true.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Response paper to a recent article related to international business
He recalls that he was among the top investors in term of his portfolio. This is after the police department started making up claims of corruption and illegal operations in his business. The firm hired a young lawyer to look into the allegations and together with some investigation expert the young lawyer managed to find evidence of corruption conspiracy among top police officials and testified against them.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Article response
The lethargic manner in which the European leaders and officials are tackling this continental financial concern is to blame for the deterioration on the condition to crisis level (Smith, 2012). Like stated in the article, the
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Article response
As such, privacy is maintained as a significant problem in modern times and that privacy should be protected at all times by application
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Response paper about an article called ''Cuba Revolutionary Projections
The 1960s has been the turning point in the history of Cuba’s cinematic genius and exposition of its art and culture. The decade was distinct
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Response paper regard of two article
In addition, she is easily distracted by circumstances around her way. All these coupled with her age and orientation makes her have the deficient integrate with other
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Write a response paper about the given article
It emerges that, most of the dictionaries in use today are insufficient in providing the meaning of words and their uses. Although many people have had the conviction that the definitions provided by many dictionaries are final and should be relied on,
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Article Response
These seasoned food led the immigrants to be nervous and unstable; hence making bad Americans. This suggests that to be an American you need to eat like
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Article Response
I agree on the point that pop/youth cultural influences have dramatically changed in their own ways over the course of time, but the basic nature and foundation have stayed the same as artists now are still talking about the same or similar things just
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation