StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Utilitarianism and Libertarianism Concerning Distributive Justice - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Utilitarianism and Libertarianism Concerning Distributive Justice" is about distributive justice holds that any policy or rules which are imposed in any given society have a purpose of serving the common and greater good. The common good also entails a fair distribution…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.9% of users find it useful
Utilitarianism and Libertarianism Concerning Distributive Justice
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Utilitarianism and Libertarianism Concerning Distributive Justice"

Describe distributive justice and how it works. thoroughly and as specifically as you can the issues between Utilitarian’s and Libertarians concerning distributive justice. Which side are you on and why?  Distributive justice holds that any policy or rules which are imposed in any given society has a purpose of serving the common and greater good. The common good also entail a fair distribution of responsibility which everybody should shoulder. Utilitarianism justice on the other hand is a form of justice that should serve an end. Any acts or choices we make are directed towards the objective of increasing happiness or pleasure or to avoid pain. In a society, this is applied to adopting policies which should serve the greatest number of people or the majority of the population and the course of action that would be untaken should have a net effect of increasing happiness.  Advocates of libertarian principles, by contrast generally criticize any distributive ideal that requires the pursuit of economic ‘patterns’, such as maximization or equality of welfare or of material goods. They argue that the pursuit of such patterns conflicts with the more important moral demands of liberty or self-ownership (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). I am more inclined to side with utilitarian justice because it is more applicable in today’s modern society that any act, policy or idea should serve the greatest number of people. It has also practical applications which in fact is even used today such the concept of progressive taxation which is really Rawl’s idea of distributive justice because this taxation takes more from the rich and gives them more to the one who has less. 2. Explain as fully as you can John Rawls “Theory of Justice” Do you agree with theory of justice? Why or why not?  In Rawl’s theory of justice, he advance two kinds of justice which is the merit theory which as the title suggests, rewards the person depending upon one’s contribution to society. The other which is more applicable to this case is the need theory which posits that society has an obligation to help other members of society who are in need which will “balance” their disadvantaged position. In his Theory of Justice, Rawl envisions a “society of free citizens holding equal basic rights cooperating within an egalitarian economic system” (STandford Encyclopedia of Philosophy).  Thus, the issue of redistributive justice follows this principle that our government ought to redistribute wealth for the purposes of making the distribution of goods more equal. This principle of redistributive justice is not only ideal but also has practical implications. Ideal because the inequalities of society will be addressed through government mechanisms such as collecting more taxes from those who earns more so that it can give more to those who have less. I agree with Rawl’s theory of justice because of its practical implication that it minimizes or blunts the cause of social upheavals which is inequality, injustice and poverty. We all know that the chaotic countries in the Third Worlds are all caused by these elements; widespread poverty, injustice and inequality. By removing or minimizing the ill effect of widespread inequity through the government’s intervention, society will become more stable and less prone to social upheavals because those who have less, will also have less reason to complain and protest against the government. Elements in society who want to sow discontent, chaos or terror will not also prosper because the people are sympathetic to the government and they cannot be agitated to go against the government because they do not feel the injustice and poverty of which chaos, anarchy and terror breeds. The other practical implication of this redistributive justice is that there will be greater social mobility in society where people has equal chance to succeed even if they have less because the government will fill in the social equation where their poverty will not prevent them in pursuing their endeavors. 3. Explain fully as you can the Buddhist Theory of Morals. DO yo think that Buddhist have anything to say todays economy morally speaking? Why or why not?  One of the noble truths in Buddhism that is applicable today’s modern society is the Way leading to the Cessation of Dukka or suffering contained in the Fourth Noble Truth. Cessation of sufferingis central to Buddhist Theory of Morals and it meant taking the “Middle Path”because it avoids the two extremes of giving in to pleasure and the other of living in ascetic, self mortificating life (Rahula 33). Both are either low, common, painful, unworthy and unprofitable and the ideal is the path between them. This theory of morality has practical application in today’s modern economy. In the language of economics, the Middle Way is in fact the middle class which is neither rich or poor of which every society and every government strives their people to be. Being rich or having excessive wealth is not good because it leads to indulgence and frivolty making the mind trivial because it does not have to work. It also weakens the moral fiber because excessiveness in itself is a vice. Being poor is worst. It breeds a lot of problem and debilitatitng apart from the fact that life will be hard. With poverty, man is basically reduced physically, morally, intellectually adn socially. Poverty weakens a man’s constitution to pursue other endeavors and aspiration that would make him or her productive. His aspiration is reduced to survival of what to eat and other basic things that he could no longer grow as a person. Poverty is also a breeding ground of other social ills such as discontent, terror and criminality. If the Buddist could have their way in today’s modern society, all if not most of us will be middle class which has a means to pursue the things that we like. We also do not worry about our survival because we already know that we have the means to survive. So we are more focused on the higher hierarchy of needs which is self actualization making us more productive and beneficial to society. Work Cited Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. “Distributive Justice”. September 22, 1996. Retrieved from http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/justice-distributive/#LibPri Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 5”, n.d.)
Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 5. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1469202-ethics
(Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 5)
Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 5. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1469202-ethics.
“Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words - 5”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1469202-ethics.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Utilitarianism and Libertarianism Concerning Distributive Justice

Michael Sandel's critique of John Rawls' Theory of Justice

This research aims to evaluate and present Michael Sandel's critique of John Rawls' Theory of justice.... Sandel's thoughts on Liberalism and the Limits of justice are the most comprehensive and extensive critique of John Rawls's Theory of justice.... It is evident from the study that in order to recover from criticism of his theory, John Rawls constantly develops recasts, revises and expands his theory of justice.... Rawls will be commemorated for his impartial model of justice as fairness....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

A Practical Discussion of Australia's Role in Ethical Policy Formation

The rationale for seeking asylum or selecting Australia as a migrant destination differ widely depending on socio-demographics in a foreign country, personal needs for security against public sources or government, or generalized personal welfare for establishment of a lifestyle in a nation that promotes justice and liberty.... Utilitarianism, Rawls' Theory of justice, Kantian Deontology, ethical relativism, and an argument of human rights must be identified and deconstructed to add support or refute arguments that asylum seekers or refugees should be turned away from Australia as a form of self-protectionism....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

The Conception of International Justice

In this theory, Rawls tries to find a solution on the issue of distributive justice by utilization of the social contract.... He argued that this principle guarantee liberties that signify meaningful options to everyone in a society and confirm distributive justice.... The Conception of International justice Name Institution THE CONCEPTION OF INTERNATIONAL justice John Rawls was born on 21st February 1921 and died on 24th November 2002....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Poverty, Hunger, and Homelessness

This report expounds on how poverty, hunger, and homelessness have developed roots in countries, their effect on the economy, and the strategies laid down to curb them.... Poor communities lack resources to acquire food due to the unemployment and the economic constrains.... ... ... ... ... Poverty refers to a situation where individuals lack basic needs to run smoothly in their day-to-day life....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Theories of Justice - Nozick's Theory of Distributive Justice, Compared to Rawls

The paper "Theories of Justice - Nozick's Theory of distributive justice, Compared to Rawls" discusses each theory in light of property and tax.... Discussion Compare and contrast Out of the four theories of distributive justice, the only theory that has the most reliability is 'justice as an entitlement.... justice is action in accord with the essential needs of law.... Issues of justice occur in a number of different spheres and regularly play an essential role in causing, enabling, as well as addressing discord....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Economic Justice Theories of Nozick and Rawls

The paper "Economic Justice Theories of Nozick and Rawls" concludes that two philosophers have done their best in explaining the issues that surround utilitarianism and libertarianism.... Based on the two eminent philosophers Nozick and Rawls, the theory of economic justice of the 1970s attempts to find a solution concerning disruptive justice by embracing the most usual tools of social interception.... The main agenda of the justice principle is to enhance fairness to society associated with the conducts of injustices....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Business ethics take home exam

Rawls claims that a rational individual in the original position would choose the principles of justice as fairness over the principle of average utility.... Since the opportunity of practicing the pivotal vote (that is, in an otherwise fixed election) is very small compared to any....
4 Pages (1000 words) Coursework

Utilitarianism with the Taxation Policy

The current paper examines the relationship between the utilitarianism and the policies followed for the redistribution of tax by the countries in the international community.... Property rights were acknowledged to be a social convention rather than a natural right, so the rules of justice were open to revision in light of new knowledge and changed circumstances.... Moreover, as Clark (2001) found the challenge confronting liberal theorists was to formulate a theory of justice in which rights were sufficiently secure to satisfy owners and sufficiently flexible to appeal to laborers....
20 Pages (5000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us