Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

In "Preventing a Brave New World" (pp. 317-329), Leon Kass concludes that reproductive and therapeutic cloning of human embryos - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare
College
Essay
Philosophy
Pages 4 (1004 words)

Summary

In "Preventing a Brave New World" Leon Kass concludes that reproductive and therapeutic cloning of human embryos is unethical. What are the exact steps in Kass's argument for this conclusion? What is your assessment of the strengths and weaknesses of this argument?…

Extract of sample
In "Preventing a Brave New World" (pp. 317-329), Leon Kass concludes that reproductive and therapeutic cloning of human embryos

He points out that “revulsion” (Kass, 2001) is not the basis of his argument as he points out that “repugnance” (Kass, 2001) of the past is silently accepted in the present. He moreover observes that disgust is not something that is emotional and hence he is not being emotional when he criticizes the cloning of the human embryos but it is a deep thought into the matter makes him talk against the mechanism. He compares cloning with the incest relationships and other unethical activities like disfigurement of corpse or feeding on human flesh. Kass observes that as murder, rape or bestiality cannot be ethically justified, in the same manner reproductive and therapeutic cloning of human embryos stands unjustified on the ground of ethics. Kass (2001), in his composition, says that cloning is resisted not only because it is strange to take up something like this but because he “intuit” that it is not novel and cloning for him is the violation of things that he dearly holds. In the book he criticizes cloning on the grounds of unethical experimentation, threatening the identity of human being and his or her individuality, transforming the essence of procreation into manufacturing. He also argues against it on the ground of despotism that it heralds on the children, thereby becoming the harbinger of parenthood perversion. He makes sure he is not misinterpreted when he is arguing against cloning. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related Essays

Human Cloning and Its Consequences
Human cloning is also wrong for other reasons, one of them being that human clones might have their bodies harvested for body parts and/or human organs. Then they would be left for dead. We must remember that every person has a soul and a spirit. People should not be grown like oranges on a tree. There has been talk about, indeed, cloning people in order to harvest their organs for one’s clone. This is not only morally reprehensible, but also ethically wrong. How one could even consider raising a human, only to use the human’s body parts for another human—is almost inconceivable. It is…
3 pages (753 words)
Preventing A Brave New World
Notably, Kass has a strong feeling that efforts should be initiated to ban human Cloning. Because of this feeling, Kass advocates for both the international community and international regulations to initiate policies that would prevent such cloning. Despite the fact that Kass admits that his ideals are exaggerated, he somewhat has a direction of truth that he has supported ideally with four reasons. Nonetheless, Kass abrasively states that there is that need due to nature that compel the humanity to decide on the issues not less than whether humanity procreation is to be terminated or it…
3 pages (753 words)
Human Cloning: Right or Wrong?
This was done through nuclear substitution, a method besides cell mass division or “embryo splitting” which is the only method applied on humans. Humans have been attempted to have been cloned for the purpose of reproduction or experimental reasons. However this is considered an unworthy means to bring more humans to life because those in favor of human cloning fail to respect the early stage of human growth which directly questions human dignity. In a situation where a person is informed that he is cloned he will instantly undergo a phase of shock after which he will question what exactly…
3 pages (753 words)
Excess Embryos and Research
Moreover, based on the absolutist principle, all life has value and that it is always wrong to take such life (West, 2005). These individuals also point out that using excess embryos for human research may lead humanity into a slippery slope, where one small step towards an end would lead to other similar actions where bigger and more undesirable consequences become apparent (West, 2005). Discussion In order to understand this discussion better, it is important to consider and define the parameters of IVF. In vitro fertilization refers to the process of the sperm fertilizing the egg outside…
6 pages (1506 words)
Utilitarian vs. Deontological Perspectives: Human Cloning
Yet, human beings have found that there may be potential benefits in creating human clones for a number of different reasons. The debate on this subject has been going on for decades and will likely continue to do so for some time. There are many different philosophical perspectives that one could apply to the issue of human cloning; it is the utilitarian and deontological perspective that offer two interesting comparative views. Human cloning has dominated science fiction for decades with scenarios revealing how the practice could go terribly wrong. Ethical debates have proposed many other…
3 pages (753 words)
New World Order: Master-Slave Dualism
New World Order: Master-Slave Dualism …
3 pages (753 words)