StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Perception Dependence Argument - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
Perception Dependence Argument

For instance, by stating that X=Y and Y=Z, it implies that X=Z. This is an example of logical arguments. However, there are arguments that are based on incorrect principles of logics, leading to logical fallacies and false or illogical conclusions. One type of argument that has attracted a lot of debates and controversy with regards to the truth about its premises and inferences/conclusions is perception-dependent argument. This paper thus evaluates whether the premises of the perception-Dependent Argument are true. In addition, the paper explores whether the argument’s inference are good. Perception Dependent Arguments The awareness or apprehension of one’s environment through senses such as sight, touch, hearing, smell, taste is referred to as perception, a study area that has continued to intrigue not only philosophers but also other scholars since historical times2. One reason perception-dependent arguments have always been considered fallacious is the problem created by the association of perception with hallucinations and illusions. Both hallucination and illusion refer to situations in which a person perceives objects in ways that in which they do not exist. Thus, the possibilities of errors occasioned by illusions and hallucinations make the true nature of arguments based on perception questionable. Because of illusion- and hallucination-related errors, arguments, their premises and inferences, always based on perception, lead to questions on whether perceptions are intuitively what they appear to be. Perceptions could therefore not be directly linked to reality and neither are they necessarily the immediate access to reality. The possibility of hallucination and illusion errors in perception dependent arguments therefore challenges the logical nature of arguments based on perceptions. Illusion refers to a situation in which an object or subject is perceived to appear in way other than it really is. For instance, using a yellow light in a house with white walls make the walls appear have yellow color. Another example of illusion is the sour taste of a sweet drink if consumed immediately after consuming a sweeter drink. It should however be noted that illusion does not imply there is deception since one is not deceived into believing that objects are not what they are. In other words, there is a possibility that one may actually be aware that he/she is experiencing an illusion. From the illusion and hallucination errors that perception dependent arguments are prone to, it is imperative that the obvious truth of peoples’ experiences and the perception-related errors in arguments are reconciled. The perceptual experiences otherwise referred to as openness to the world, which lead to true premises and good inferences in arguments, have been consistently challenged by the existence of illusions and hallucinations. From its definition, it is apparent that basing one’s arguments on illusion will most likely result in false premises and bad conclusions/inferences. Arguments based on perceptions (illusions and hallucinations) always occur through certain steps. When one is under illusion, an object appears to have some characteristic or quality F. In reality, the object under view, feel, taste, or touch does not always have the perceived quality. Interestingly, another object encountered or experienced somewhere by the person under illusion possesses the quality/feature F perceived by the person. In ...Show more


[Name of Student] [Name of Lecturer] Philosophy [Date] Perception Dependence Argument Introduction The two elements that are characteristic of any type or form of argument are premise(s) and conclusion(s)1. An argument must therefore begin with one or two premises and end with a conclusion(s)…
Author : abelardo41
Perception Dependence Argument essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Perception Dependence Argument"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Sensation and perception are largely intertwined with the neuroscience of how our body works. Our brain plays a big part in the reception and perception of our environment. There have been many misconceptions about the relation in regards to both sensation and perception.
10 pages (2500 words) Research Paper
Likewise, the following tasks were required to be performed: Step 1: Access the following website: Step 2: Choose one of the perception topics from the site and work through the tutorial. Step 3: Write a one page summary of the topic chosen in Step 2.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Computer Dependence: The Effects
The human population is becoming increasingly dependent on computers that people tend to “computerize” everything – almost every little thing is controlled remotely and digital. They are used in business, healthcare, crime detections, and even in transportation.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Dependence on Cell Phones
According to the report the smart phone has internet services along with the normal communication functions which appeal to the everyday student more than anyone else; this is because students are in constant need of information for their studies, research, homework, papers as well as travelling and living away from home.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Alcohol Dependence
Alcoholism is a term with multiple and sometimes conflicting definitions. In common and historic usage, alcoholism refers to any condition which results in the continued consumption of alcoholic beverages despite health problems and negative social consequences.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Substance Abuse and Dependence
(Volkow, 2004) The effect of this abuse is apparent in many areas of life, and includes health and social concerns, the emotional and mental anguish to the patient and the persons close to them, and the effects it can produce on a broader scale on the different sectors of life.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Drug Dependence
With this, one might conclude that what drives a certain person determines his course of action.In the same way, if we are to further analyze drug addiction in relation to criminality and vice versa, there are no human beings who can be categorized as criminal or drug addict but there are things that triggered a certain person form him to be classified as such.
15 pages (3750 words) Essay
The acquisition of desirable leadership traits does not only stem from learning about the positive qualities of a leader, but is a continuous process of learning,
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Explore and analyse the nature of perception, cognitive dissonance, memory and context dependence in relation firstly to Twelve Angry Men (URL below). Students must then apply this analysis to the demise of ENRON, focusing on which of these psychological
Decision making is usually performed in a state of doubt or uncertainty. The project is also subjected to irrational thoughts and biases. Making a rational decision is undoubtedly a challenge.
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
When I went home and showed the scraped sides of the car to my dad, he immediately began shouting about my reckless behavior and poor driving skills. After analyzing the scenario, I can see that the fundamental attribution error had a
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment