StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Euthanasia and our civilization - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay begins with a referral to James Rachels, who in his article Active and Passive Euthanasia describes the moral differences between active and passive euthanasia. Then throughout the essay, the ethical and moral issues of euthanasia are discussed…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.5% of users find it useful
Euthanasia and our civilization
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Euthanasia and our civilization"

?Euthanasia Part One: Summary Digest James Rachels in his article Active and Passive Euthanasia describes the moral differences between active and passive euthanasia. He has pointed out that the conventional doctrine about euthanasia is that there is such an important moral difference between the two that, although the latter is sometimes permissible, the former is always forbidden. He has challenged this notion and argued that active euthanasia is ethically more acceptable than passive euthanasia because of the following reasons: Active euthanasia is in many cases more humane than passive euthanasia. The conventional doctrine leads to decisions concerning life and death on irrelevant grounds. The doctrine rests on a distinction between killing and letting die that itself has no moral importance (Rachels 1) James Rachel pointed out that mercy killing or the intentional termination of the life of one human being by another is against the norms of medical profession and the policy of the American Medical Association. It is ethical for a doctor to withdraw the treatment of a patient in no hope condition because of the requests made by the patient and his relatives. However, the patient may intensify his pain and agony because of the withdrawal of treatment. In this case, active euthanasia should be considered more moral than passive euthanasia since the withdrawal of treatment may intensify the pain and agony of the patient for the remaining period of his life. In other words, the purpose of euthanasia may not be served in the cases of passive euthanasia. Rachels pointed out that “the process of being "allowed to die" can be relatively slow and painful, whereas being given a lethal injection is relatively quick and painless” (Rachels 2). James Rachel’s second argument is that some people perform passive euthanasia on irrelevant grounds. He has made this point clear with an example of an infant with Down syndrome. Such children may require a surgery to remove the intestinal obstructions that require operations if they are to live. However, some parents may not perform such surgeries and let the child die. In this case, “It is the Down's syndrome, and not the intestines, that is the issue” (Rachels 3). The third argument of Rachels is that killing (active euthanasia) and letting die (passive euthanasia) are controlled by the same motive: personal gain. Therefore, nobody can argue that letting die is better than killing in certain cases. “If a doctor lets a patient die, for humane reasons, he is in the same moral position as if he had given the patient a lethal injection for humane reasons” (Rachels 4). Arthur J. Dyck in his article An alternative to the ethic of Euthanasia argued against all forms of euthanasia. In his opinions, euthanasia is a dangerous policy and it is impossible to support a social policy in which people kill themselves. Compassion for those who are painfully ill and the concern for human dignity associated with the freedom are the major arguments cited in favour of euthanasia. Dyck has argued that these values have nothing to do with the process of dying. Regardless of the method employed for, the ultimate result of all forms of euthanasia is the same; the patient’s life is shortened. If one can justify the shortening of life using a method, then others forms of shortening life also be justified based on the utilitarian principles of ethics. Instead of euthanasia, Dyck put forward another term called benemortasia or happy death. Benemortasia provides the choice of how to live to while dying. “How a person dies has a definite meaning for those to whom that person is related. In the first year of bereavement, the rate of death among the bereaved relatives of those die in hospitals is twice that of the bereaved relatives of those who die at home” (Dyck 254). Joy and suffering are part of life and it is the duty if the community to provide assistance to those who suffers. Encouraging people to commit suicide is the failure of a society. It is dangerous to allow a physician to decide whether a patient’s life is not worth living. Physicians are also human beings and they can commit medical errors or wrong diagnosis of the disease. In short, even a dying patient cannot argue that his life is worthless and, therefore, committing any kind of euthanasia is immoral. On January 17, 2006, the Supreme Court ruled that the 1970 Controlled Substances Act (CSA) does not give the U.S. attorney general the authority to prohibit Oregon doctors from prescribing lethal doses of drugs to certain terminally ill patients who want to end their own lives. The court's decision in Gonzales v. Oregon resolves a conflict between the state's Death with Dignity Act (DWDA) and the attorney general's interpretation of the federal drug statute. Oregon is currently the only state that has an assisted-suicide law. The Supreme Court, by a 6-3 vote, ruled that the Directive exceeded the powers that Congress granted to the attorney general under the CSA. The court, thus, affirmed a ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit that had held the Directive "unlawful and unenforceable."(“Supreme Court's Decision in Gonzales v. Oregon”) Part Two: Personal Analysis Rachels’ argument that active euthanasia is more acceptable morally than passive euthanasia seems to be illogical in my opinion. In my opinion, life and death are still beyond the grasping capacities of human. Even after huge advancements in science and technology, we are still unable to unveil the secrets behind birth and life after death. Majority of the people in this world has some belief in the existence of God. They believe that God send us to this world with a mission and it is immoral to commit suicide before the completion of that mission. Even a dying person may teach lot of lessons to others. We come to this world unintentionally. In other words, nobody knows about his life in this world prior to their birth. Same way, nobody knows what happens to his soul after death. Even science accepts the existence of a soul in human body. It is believed that the soul is the energy which is driving human body. Scientific principles say that energy can neither be created nor be destroyed. Under such circumstances, it is logical to think that soul or the energy detaches from our body at the time of death and stay alive somewhere, even though we do not have any knowledge about this energy after the death. Human life is the most precious thing in this world. It should be noted that nobody can return it once it is taken. Only the creator has the right to destroy or modify his creations. Passive and active euthanasia are processes which are destroying the creations of an unknown power. Hence, both forms of euthanasia are immoral and illogical. There are plenty of incidents in which patients whose life were written off by the doctors, recover well after some time. In other words, no doctor can say ultimate word about a person’s future life. In fact, he cannot predict his own future. It is quite possible that the doctor who is assisting a patient top commit suicide may lose his life at the very next moment. Nobody can predict or control the future of a person. In short, life and death are beyond our control and it is logical to let it finish by itself. Euthanasia may not be a suitable option for a civilized world like ours. Increased rate of euthanasia definitely reflects the failure of the society. Works Cited Dyck, Arthur J. “An Alternative to the Ethic of Euthanasia”. Web. 04 June 2012. http://www.philosophicalturn.net/CMI/Euthanasia/Dyck_Alternative_to_euthanasia.pdf Rachels, James. “Active and Passive Euthanasia”. Web. 04 June 2012. http://www2.sunysuffolk.edu/pecorip/scccweb/etexts/deathanddying_text/Active%20and%20Passive%20Euthanasia.pdf “Supreme Court's Decision in Gonzales v. Oregon”. 2006. Web. 04 June 2012. http://pewresearch.org/pubs/4/supreme-courts-decision-in-gonzales-v-oregon Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Euthanasia and our civilization Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Euthanasia and our civilization Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1452654-euthanasia-and-our-civilization
(Euthanasia and Our Civilization Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Euthanasia and Our Civilization Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1452654-euthanasia-and-our-civilization.
“Euthanasia and Our Civilization Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1452654-euthanasia-and-our-civilization.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Euthanasia and our civilization

Euthanasia Mercy Killing

Discussion There are many biological and medical issues that are not being resolved satisfactorily by the present state of our medical ethics today.... Professor's Name: euthanasia (Mercy Killing) 02 March 2011 Introduction Life is the most precious possession any person can have.... euthanasia or mercy killing is just one bio-medical issue that has hounded healthcare professionals and legal practitioners alike.... The questions regarding euthanasia are many and very convoluted; there are no easy answers here....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Attitudes of nursing towards euthanasia

Ultimately, the position that many nurses will find themselves in may be one of conflict, as many current laws regarding euthanasia and assisted suicide are unclear about the participation of nurses.... In April 2001, the Netherlands established the world's first law regulating euthanasia (De Beer, et al.... A year later, Belgium followed suit and passed a similar law to regulate euthanasia (De Beer, et al.... 2003). As other countries begin to contemplate similar laws, we must consider the position of nurses amidst the euthanasia controversy-not just their physical involvement, but their emotional involvement, legal position, and the spiritual conflicts they may encounter along the way. This topic is relevant to many as it addresses the truth that euthanasia is a reality for everyone....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

International Terrorism (Answer the questions)

What does this model for culture and civilization around the world have to do with terrorism What are the implications for law enforcement if terrorism has deeper roots-namely, rooted in a clash of civilizations Also, what are the implications for American foreign policy efforts to thwart terrorism 5.... This issue of three different perceptions of an act - the terrorist, the victim, and the public - that leads to different understandings and definitions of the act is part of our common experience (Schmid, 1997)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Scholarship Essay

Different Christian Views Surrounding Euthanasia

hellip; It is evidently clear from the discussion that euthanasia can be active or passive.... When a physician takes action to induce death using morphine or insulin, it is known as active (also known as direct) euthanasia.... Passive euthanasia (or indirect) on the other hand is to withdraw treatment and allow the patient to die.... euthanasia can be voluntary, non-voluntary, (when the patient requests to be killed) or involuntary....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Ethical Problem of Euthanasia

They say that our bodies are our own, and we ought to be permitted to do what we need with them.... This work called "Ethical Problem of euthanasia" describes an extensive variety of significantly hindering impacts because of sanctioning euthanasia.... The author takes into account a continuous debate about whether the act of euthanasia ought to be made legitimate or not focused on its qualities, shortcomings, and moral issues surrounding it....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Euthanasia and Physician Assisted Suicide - Morally and Professionally Repugnant Activities

This paper under the headline 'euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide - Morally and Professionally Repugnant Activities" focuses on the fact that suicide is a nettlesome ethical problem.... Unlike euthanasia, PAS involves the physician as a facilitator of patient termination, one in which the patient still participates, in however limited a fashion, as an active participant.... Putting a patient, terminal or otherwise, to death in order to end intractable pain and suffering defines active euthanasia....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Arguments for and against Euthanasia

The paper examines the moral concerns surrounding euthanasia, clarify the meaning of the term, present arguments both for and against the practice and conclude with a recommendation to resolve an issue.... Health care professionals cite the Hippocratic Oath which forbids from carrying out the procedure … Opponents to legal euthanasia rightly claim that the practice would be in violation of the Hippocratic Oath.... more so than in many other countries, therefore, the decisions other countries make regarding euthanasia are not relevant  The practice would lessen the urgency to develop new medicines designed to prolong life....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Exploring the Effects of Euthanasia

hellip; Around 400 BC, Hippocrates opposed the practice of euthanasia; however, without him knowing that during the ancient Greek and Roman civilization, euthanasia has already been practiced.... The present discourse “Exploring the Effects of euthanasia” investigates the concern in the moral issues of the mercy killing which has been arguably growing with the development of palliative care services that provokes significantly moral thinking on the care of the dying patients....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us