StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Desire to have Children - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Desire to have Children

Finally, they decided to attempt in vitro fertilization. Mary Sue supplied nine eggs for the procedure, and her husband supplied sperm, which medical experts used to fertilize all the nine eggs in a laboratory. The medical personnel implanted two eggs in Mary Sue’s womb, but pregnancy did not result. The medical personnel froze the remaining seven fertilized eggs in order to preserve them for future use. Sometime later, the couple divorced, but they disagreed on who between them should claim the fertilized eggs and to what use they should be put. Mar Sue claimed ownership of the fertilized eggs and expressed the desire to have them implanted in her body. Junior opposed Mary Sue’s claim of ownership and intention to implant the eggs. Instead, he wanted them destroyed. Mary Sue filed a law suit in court regarding the case. The judge ruled in her favor and granted her temporary custody of the fertilized eggs, so as to avail Mary Sue the chance to achieve a normal pregnancy by having medical experts implant the eggs in her womb. The rationale of this decision was that human life begins at conception and, therefore, the fertilized eggs were persons who have the right to the provision of suitable conditions and support that would allow them to develop into normal human beings. The judge added that the final custody of the child, child support, and visitation would be decided by the same court if one of the eggs results in birth. II. Ethical Question to be Answered Was Judge W. Dale Young morally justified in regarding the fertilized eggs as persons that have a right to life and not as property? III. Proposed Answers to Ethical Question Judge Young’s decision was not morally justified because the frozen fertilized eggs were not naturally conceived and, therefore, this argument does not parallel the ones put forward by opponents of abortion. It is appropriate to regard the fertilized eggs as property because medical experts created them artificially and, therefore, are the creation of human beings. In addition, the fertilized eggs do not have a societal, moral responsibility and; thus, they cannot be regarded as persons. A person has a moral role to play in society, the fertilized eggs do not. IV. Objections to Proposed Answers and Responses to the Objections Objection (1): The conceptus is a living human being because the continuous process of growth and development of human beings begins at conception. Therefore, the frozen fertilized eggs should be regarded as conceptus since they came into existence as a result of conception. Whether conception takes place in a woman’s body or scientists induce it artificially in the laboratory, fact is it leads to the creation of a human life form, the zygote. Response (1): The conceptus does not have any of the functions of a human being and, therefore, cannot be bestowed with the same status as a human being living in the real world. Fertilized eggs are just a mass of cells which scientists or medical experts keep alive through artificial means, without whose assistance they will surely die. A zygote that medical experts create and preserve through an artificially regulated process is not a real form of human life. This is because it is not supported or sustained in any way by the life processes that manifest themselves through nature. The same way that a graft of skin cells obtained from a person represents a living part of that person, it cannot be regarded as a person because they lack any of the moral functions associated with a person. Objection (2): God imparts a soul onto human beings at conception and not at birth since birth is just a transition from the womb into the world. The life of the baby did not begin at birth, but it was alive from the moment of conception. Since every human ...Show more

Summary

A married couple, Mary Sue and Junior Davis, unsuccessfully tried five times to have children. Each of those five attempts resulted in a tubal pregnancy, necessitating the need to terminate the pregnancy…
Author : virginia40
Desire to have Children essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Desire to have Children"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Money, Freedom, desire
However, the definitions of freedom arch wildly from sphere to sphere, each community recognizing different forms and different constraints that are a threat. However, the concept of freedom does not exist, the human animal having physical needs that must be met, cognitive development that requires outside stimulation, and the need for socialization that is important to emotional development making human interaction vital for survival.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
LOVE and Desire ESSAY
From a neutral perspective, Sommers appears as one focused on ensuring equity and not one who seeks to establish a ‘matriarchal’ society. A keen look at radical feminism at its height illustrates a struggle which was not only aimed at achieving equal opportunities for women but one that also sought to overturn the ‘sexual balance of society’.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Society and Desire
The sociologist studies the person does or does not do when he or she is alone or when he or she is with his close friends and relatives or when he or she is in an association or institution or groups and also how and why the actions or reactions in one given situation may be different in another situation.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Children
Children are strange creatures. Understanding them as they grow up to become adults is one of the most difficult jobs. What goes inside a child’s mind when the child cannot speak is anybody’s guess.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Power, Desire, Difference
Of course any notion of opposition between psychoanalysis and politics has to be qualified: psychoanalysis is a thoroughly political entity. The question here is one of context and emphasis. If psychical processes are emphasized, as they are in the context of Lacan's theory of the symbolic, this contextual emphasis needs to be taken into account before a political critique can be fully elaborated, before politics can figure in a productive way, taking account of psychical issues, rather than closing its eyes to them.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Richard Rodriguez The Achievement of Desire
He has discovered early on that his schooling has triggered a disjointing between him along with his parents. He has been writing the narration of his schooling with the intention of honoring his subordinate-class setting and gave value on how he turned out to be the man he has become today.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
The achievement of desire
The uniqueness and value of this essay is that it describes real life experience of the writer and his personal problems and vision of cultural diversity in America. Thesis Diversity and gap in ethnic relations between his parents and Rodriguez, becomes a driven force for educational achievements and desire to develop his own identity and personality.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Female desire in literature
Charlotte Bront(1816-55), Kate Chopin(1850-1904) and Mary Austin(1868-1934) are three women who dared to discuss the truth of female sexuality and desire, much in advance of their society. The translucence of the veil that shrouds female sexuality in fiction today derives its quality from the courage of these pioneer 'feminists.'
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Female desire in literature
Charlotte Brontë(1816-55), Kate Chopin(1850-1904) and Mary Austin(1868-1934) are three women who dared to discuss the truth of female sexuality and desire,
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Society And Desire
This new science is generally known as the study of society where a man or a woman lives in. what is also studied what he or she does in the society or environment that he lives in. The sociologist is the scientist that studies what are common and unorthodox reactions a man or woman does in any society situation.
11 pages (2750 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation