StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

The Schiavo : Ethics and the End of Life : What have you Learned from this Dilemma - Case Study Example

Free

Extract of sample
The Schiavo : Ethics and the End of Life : What have you Learned from this Dilemma

Recently, one such ethical consideration presented itself in the life of the family members of Terri Schiavo. Schiavo is an individual that had lost higher brain functions and had been relegated to a bed and a feeding tube. Schiavo’s parents desire was to keep her alive, while her husband believed it was Schiavo’s desire to remove the feeding tube. The incident presents a number of ethical questions related to end of life issues. This essay considers the various issues surrounding this case, and articulates what I learned from this dilemma. In considering the various ethical elements surrounding the Terri Schiavo dilemma there are a number of things I learned. One of the primary elements I learned to consider was the nature of ethical considerations in the realm of secular and non-secular concerns. Within the spectrum of the Terri Schiavo dilemma it seems apparent that one of the primary concerns arises as an element of Schiavo’s parents Roman Catholic beliefs. The ethical dilemma is presented as a concern between her family members over medical concerns, with Schiavo’s parents indicating that they believe she has the potential to wake from her state and her husband indicating not believing this is possible. Still, it seems that most evidence indicates that Schiavo has truly lost higher-level brain functioning. In these regards, their religious perspective largely influences Schiavo’s parents. It seems that such decisions must be established on firmer ethical grounds than spirituality.

Related Essays

The Case of Sherry Ethical dilemma
The case of Sherry presents one such ethical dilemma. Identifying the Ethical Dilemma The ethical dilemma here is very clearly that of using marijuana and selling drugs to make ends meet. It is understandable that Sherry finds herself in a very difficult situation.
3 pages (750 words) Case Study
ATC-47 Ethical Dilemma - Terry Bailey Case
Yes, Terry’s scheme does affect balance sheet of Fairwell Furniture. Under the Current Assets head, the Bank Account Balance would have reduced and on the Liabilities side of the Balance Sheet, the Profit and Loss Account balance would have reduced. Both would have reduced by the amount accounted as paid to Larry Tyler.By capitalizing a revenue item of expenditure, Wilson Blowhard is misrepresenting the facts.
2 pages (500 words) Case Study
Medical Ethics Case Study
All the other cases were dictated by one of other three reasons that can become the ground for abortion according to the 1967 Abortion Act Termination of pregnancy is a serious decision both for the women, and for the practitioner, who treats her. To terminate the life of the unborn fetus, serious reasons have to exist.
8 pages (2000 words) Case Study
Medical Ethics: Moral Dilemma
The parents requests no more further medical attention to let the child just die. According to them there are no support mechanisms for such a child in their country. He will just be the subject of jokes and ridicule Given a choice, would you choose to live or die Would you like to experience life even if you are afflicted with severe mental retardation But in that state, would you understand the essence of life Besides what kind of life and living would that be Are these fears baseless or mere suppositions that might or might not happen But why risk it Why make the child suffer from a bleak or uncertain future Why Because as they say: "while there is life, there is hope" Again,
2 pages (500 words) Case Study
IKEA Business Ethics Dilemma
Choices of this kind must be forced upward in the corporation; for--as one assumes increased obligations toward employees and stockholders-profit itself represents an ethical standard. IKEA adopts social corporate responsibility policies in order to meet ethical and moral questions and respond effectively to changing demands and laws.
9 pages (2250 words) Case Study
ETHICS CASE
Organizations have a duty to ensure that their operations, rules and regulations, and organizations policies do not adversely affect its stakeholders. In the case, the stakeholders that affected are the managers, customers and sales personnel, and
1 pages (250 words) Case Study
Ethics Case
industry and should remain persistently vigilant to decrease the likelihood of outside forces influencing financial records, which could lead to both criminal and ethical violation. (Moore 19). The trouble for public organizations and companies to be successful at high levels
1 pages (250 words) Case Study
Ethics Case
It is usually private and confidential such that no employee should feel unsafe while expressing themselves. The hotline will enable the employees shout out their concerns and other
2 pages (500 words) Case Study
SALES ETHICS CASE STUDY: SALES PERSON'S DILEMMA
However, Janet was approached by Sy Abell who has set three key conditions for establishing cooperation with the Daily News: information on Godowskis expenditures and schedules, guaranteed page positions, and a 33 percent discount off
5 pages (1250 words) Case Study
Ethics Case
Accuracy and honesty in accounting are financial and ethical issues that should be given attention by any professional accountant (Amat & Gowthorpe, 2013). Maryam Mohammed should be able to conduct herself as per the code
3 pages (750 words) Case Study
Another major thing I learned related to the nature of ethical decision-making. Having never experienced such a life-pressing dilemma as occurred in the Schiavo case, it was surprising to discover that there was not a readily established chain of decision-making. While one would think to trust Schiavo’s husband, this issue is further complicated by potential financial or legal motivations he might have to see her die early. The case notes, “Providing clear direction is a gift we can give to those who love us, a gift that avoids putting them in the agonizing situation of trying to make choices on our behalf without knowing what we would want” (Hinman & Kalichman). Ultimately, the failure of such a process or structure of decision making greatly contributed to the ethical challenges of this specific case. Another element that was learned related to the need for increased awareness and legal structure to be established in relation to end of life issues. In researching end-of-life issues one of the most pervasive such contemporary considerations occurs in the case of Dr. Jack Kevorkian; it’s noted that, “Dr. Jack Kevorkian was found guilty of second-degree murder for ending the life of a terminally ill man” (Hinman). In these regards, it seems that there is considerable debate regarding questions related to the legal elements of end of life issues. The very notion that an individual should have to go to a black market doctor to find an option for euthanasia is indicative of the tremendous ethical challenges within this realm of medical care. While religious principles have historically functioned as cornerstone elements of many moral decisions throughout society, it seems that in questions of end-of-life decisions they have held back progress in legal decision-making. Few would contend that religion should be prohibited, but just as restrictions are placed on the extent that spirituality can influence

Summary

Case Study: The Schiavo Case: Ethics and the End of Life: What Have You Learned From this Dilemma? While ethics is an area of investigation that dates back to at least ancient Greek philosophy, it is also a discipline that must be continually re-examined and considered in light of cultural and technological changes…
Author : kertzmannlawren
The Schiavo Case: Ethics and the End of Life : What have you Learned from this Dilemma essay example
Read Text Preview
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation