StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Chinese Influence on Western Art: Flattery, or Something Much More Sinister - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Your Name Prof’s Name Date The Chinese Influence on Western Art: Flattery, or Something Much More Sinister? There is an English saying that “imitation is the most sincere form of flattery” which essentially means that if one imitates something it must meant that they value that quality or that object very highly, otherwise they would not be likely to copy it…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.8% of users find it useful
The Chinese Influence on Western Art: Flattery, or Something Much More Sinister
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Chinese Influence on Western Art: Flattery, or Something Much More Sinister"

Download file to see previous pages

Chinese influence on Western art is not just that Westerners enjoyed the forms of Chinese art and wanted to produce things that looked similar because they were beautiful: this would be a relatively sincere form of flattery to Chinese art. Instead, what they seemed to enjoy most about Chinese art was the fact that it was exotic, which is no different than current people collecting tribal art from Africa with no knowledge of the culture or anything like that. This thus does not represent a sincere form of flattery, but something more sinister.

I would argue that China’s main appeal was that it was exotic, which meant that Westerners formed a distorted and over-simplified view of Chinese people and culture, which could have played a part in the West’s frequent aggression towards China during 18th and 19th centuries. In composing this essay I visited the Chinese National Museum to view elements of both Chinese and Western art based on Chinese art. I then selected three images that I believe would be able to construct a prototypical image of Chinese art: an Octoginal Jar with Iranian Brass Mounts, a Pair of Decorative Candle Sticks, and Candlesticks and Altar Vase with Biscuit Applied Overglaze enamels.

Each of these was an indigenously produced piece of Chinese art, and in putting them together one can begin to construct fundamental aspects of Chinese art. These are things like repetitive blue decoration, often featuring a flower motif, which often repeats but is not entirely formulaic, as seen with the decorations on the alter pieces. These pieces seem to be expressions of similar aesthetic principles, which simultaneously value cohesion and repetitiveness as well as uniqueness. On the surface, an English piece, the Blue-and-White serving platter, mirrors many of these ideas.

It has the prototypical Chinese blue decoration on a white background, and so forth. However, a closer examination shows that it is somewhat more sinister. Firstly, it simply shows a greater attention to symmetry than Chinese pieces, with things like the direction of scrolls being mirrored across a central axis. This shows that English were already using elements of Chinese culture, but adapting them to their own sensibilities. More problematic, however, is the fact that content of the decoration is not Chinese at all.

Chinese art has things like flower or art motifs, occasionally with symbolically important animals such as dragons. This piece, however, seems to trade entirely on the exoticism of China: it includes elements that are solely there to show how “Chinese” the piece is, such as scrolls and vases, which would never actually be put on Chinese art. This work thus seems to render exotic the Chinese, and play on how strange Chinese culture is, rather than paying it any respect. This seems to mirror the ways many westerners thought about the Chinese people: they were certainly remarkable, but mostly just strange.

For instance, in 1753, “The wife of the king of Sweden” was given an elaborate display that was supposed to be attached to her love of China. What occurred, however, was a “ridiculous” display, in which a group of people imitating Chinese cultural practices such as dance performing Chinese solutes and so forth (Jacobson, 94). This shows that the West did not value Chinese

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Chinese Influence on Western Art: Flattery, or Something Much More Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1455099-chinese-art-influence-western-art
(The Chinese Influence on Western Art: Flattery, or Something Much More Essay)
https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1455099-chinese-art-influence-western-art.
“The Chinese Influence on Western Art: Flattery, or Something Much More Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1455099-chinese-art-influence-western-art.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Chinese Influence on Western Art: Flattery, or Something Much More Sinister

Race and Nation in Japan

In this way, Historian's' writings reveal more about himself and their times, than they do about Japan.... Historian's, in short, argues that human biology (Aryan blood) can account for much of the success of the Japanese, and that power struggles between nations can be viewed as an evolutionary struggle between races.... Japan, however, had bushed" (the way of the samurai) which helped galvanize the nation, something which the British could learn from....
14 Pages (3500 words) Term Paper

Critical IPE Study: Association of southeast Asian Country

Less obvious to the outside observer but certainly part of the driving force behind the development of ASEAN was the desire to solve Asian problems in an Asian way rather than by imitating western solutions (Mahapatra 1990: 6).... When it was first formed, the ASEAN member nations intended it to draw them together into a unified regionalist entity that would reduce dependence on foreign powers, particularly… The member nations were third world countries that had up to that time relied heavily on foreign markets, and one of the goals of regionalism was to combine the resources of the countries and convert them from five individual weak entities into one strong entity capable of As a result of this drawing together, it was hoped that regional unity would naturally result and that economic integration within the region would be easier to facilitate....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Japanese influence on Van Gogh

It's just as he declined to quit taking a shot at a photo, adding more color to it, until he felt that some sort of visual identicalness for feeling had been accomplished.... Van Gogh was one of the most passionate collectors, and studiers of Japanese art.... Van Gogh's comprehension of the traditions of Japanese prints is apparent, as seems to be, maybe, his attention to Japanese materials, however these works of art talk the same amount of to his own pleasure in tight center and close examination - or to his yearning for the quieting impact of looking steadily at a piece of turf that he portrays in his letter to Wilhelmina - as they do to his enthusiasm for the disentanglements of Japanese models....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Internet Censorship in the Peoples Republic of China

y Western democratic standards, the chinese governments' pattern of information control is inconsistent with age old concepts of freedom of expression and the right of the people to freely receive and impart information.... nbsp; In accepting the economic benefits of the internet China has taken a more liberal approach to the control of information over the internet.... The purpose of the articles contained in this study is to examine the methods of internet censorship in China and how it is perceived in both China and in the western world....
68 Pages (17000 words) Research Paper

How Did The Cold War Influence on International Relations

The fall of the Soviet Union has something important to say about the organization of social life, namely that the combination of some kind of representative democracy is the only effective way of running complex industrial and postindustrial societies.... This paper, International Relations after the Second World War, presents International Relations which is the study of international relations (lower case), but what are international relations?...
22 Pages (5500 words) Research Paper

Comparison of the Economies of China and Japan

the chinese civilization is one of the oldest civilizations in the world with over 5000 years of narrated history.... Japan was flourishing for three or more decades in the last century whereas China is flying high in the current decade.... Now it is in the experimental state to combine the strengths of Chinese and western culture.... and De-imperialized in World War II has various cultural and social influence of Chinese civilization and religious similarities....
21 Pages (5250 words) Essay

Role of Media in Policy Making

This essay looks into media, which holds extensive powers to affect and mold our lives.... Through television and internet, which are the two most popular and impactful forms of media, they can now reach into every corner of our lives.... Mass media has come into existence.... hellip; From this paper, it is clear that the recent advent of breaking news has further decreased the time that took this news broadcast to reach to the global viewers....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Diversity in Japanese Society

The Burakumin community is assumed to be a community with evil deeds, and most other tribes are not comfortable with their practices, forcing them to flee away and live in another place where they feel more comfortable (Okano & Tsuchiya 1999).... After the introduction of formal education, scholars emerged who studied this theory deeply and with much interest....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us