Constitutional Law of the EU - Case Study Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Constitutional Law of the EU

Individuals were given the right to bring actions before the ECJ for judicial review of the acts of Community institutions under Article 173. However, as a means of enforcing individual rights, this Article has limited utility as, first, individuals are not permitted to bring actions against Member States and therefore have no rights or remedies where a State violates their Community law rights and, secondly, individuals are required to demonstrate that the measure is a decision which is of direct and individual concern to the applicant.
An individual cannot challenge regulations unless it is demonstrable that it is merely a decision in the garb of a regulation1. The individual must show that the effects of the decision apply directly to the applicant without depending on the exercise of discretion by another body2. Moreover, the decision must affect the individual's legal position3. The ECJ has taken its own view as to the nature and effect of treaties known as the doctrine of 'direct effect.'
The concept of Direct Effect of EC law was developed by the ECJ to allow individuals and organisations to use the provisions of EC law within their Member States' domestic courts without having to wait for the Member State to fulfil some obligation which it had omitted to do. ...
Download paper


The provisions of the EC Treaty which explicitly provide for individuals to enforce rights derived from European Community law are limited in their scope. The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has therefore developed a number of principles which widens this scope…
Author : mshields

Related Essays

EU Law
The first elections of the European parliament “by direct universal suffrage” took place in June 1979 (Europa, 2007). Since then these elections take place every five years giving more strength and responsibility to the Parliament. In European Union, EP is the only directly elected body. Every five year, 27 member states select 736 Members, which represent 500 million people of EU (EuroParl, 2011a). It covers every sphere of EU’s citizens life; civil, social, political, economical and environmental. Its domain of control is huge. Gradually EU’s parliament has gained a position of “co...
9 pages (2259 words) Essay
Rights of residence Member states will issue the right of residence to nationals of the member states who are not enjoying other provisions of the community law which has been provided that they themselves and the their family members are covered by medical insurance in respect of all the risks in the host member state and have sufficient resources, which will be able to sustain them and avoid being a burden to the social security system of the host member state during their period of residence. All the citizens of the union have the right to enter another member state by only possessing a...
10 pages (2510 words) Essay
Preliminary References Essay
It therefore has some certain procedure to be followed. The procedure here is reference rather than precedence since any national court in the union does not take any precedence from the EU law. An example can be taken from the procedure provided for by Art 267 TFEU (Art 234 EC: Art 177 EEC) 1which suggests a system of co-operation between national courts and CJ within their respective jurisdictions (laid out by the article), not a hierarchical system2. The two courts should always act as equals in addressing legal matters. For instance, a national court of a member state decides whether and...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Constitutional Administrative Law Essay
This supranational policy has greatly affected the sovereignty of member states. The attainment of the United Kingdom (UK) to the European Communities (EC) membership forces it to effect community law in the country. This paper will critically analyse and evaluate how the United Kingdom courts have initiated the community law effectiveness over principles of domestic law, parliamentary sovereignty inclusive. Evaluation of the UK Courts achievements Chief sources of community law emanate from the secondary and primary legislations, which bind the member nations onto the law’s subject. Primary...
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
"The efficacy of the principle of supremacy of EU law depends on its reception in national constitutional courts." Discuss.
Despite being recognized by member states, there are particular reservations made by the national constitutional courts that challenge the principle of supremacy of the Community law. They view supremacy as an ideology rooted in national constitutions instead of being derived from the nature of Community legal order.1 Based on this notion, the constitutional courts possess the right to evaluate whether the European Union institutions conduct themselves within the competences given to them and respect the fundamental human rights and constitutional norms. An example of such cases include the...
10 pages (2510 words) Essay
Parliamentary Sovereignty
During the 1880s, Oxford Professor A.V. Dicey proposed a theory of Parliamentary sovereignty that encompassed a hierarchal constitutional structure with Parliament reigning supreme. Dicey’s theory of Parliamentary sovereignty has wielded significant influence over definitions and concepts of Parliamentary sovereignty until recently. Specifically, Dicey argued that Parliament, elected by and representing the public, had the authority to make and unmake any law. Moreover, according to Dicey, the power of Parliament is so absolute that no other body has the authority to “override” an act of...
5 pages (1255 words) Coursework
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!