Insanity and Diminished Responsibility - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Insanity and Diminished Responsibility

abnormality of the mind ( R v Byrne ); drug personality disorder (Celebici Trial); involuntary intoxication ( R v Galbraith) ; mental weakness and low intelligence ( Lord Dea's decision ) ; minority ( R v Raven ); physical deformities such as blindness and being a deaf-mute ( R v Pritchard). In the treatise "Partial Defences To Murder" more mitigating factors are added i.e. sufficient provocation by the offended party ( R v Smith ); immediate vindication of a grave offence to himself or his relatives (Table 7); Incomplete self-defence where there is no reasonable necessity of the means employed by the culprit (R v Martin); passion or obfuscation (Case 113); disease or injury (Note 17); jealousy, mercy killing, depression, relationship of victim to the accused (Table 7). The list goes on and on.
Insanity is a plea or defence by which the accused at the time of the commission of the act, "was laboring under such a defect of reason, arising from a disease of the mind, as not to know the nature and quality of the act he was doing or, if he did know it, that he did not know that what he was doing was wrong (The M'Naghten Rules). Insanity totally exempts the culprit from criminal liability unless he does it during a lucid interval. If so, he is wholly liable for the crime unless there are mitigating factors attending the crime.
Diminished Respons ...
Download paper


The first thing one observes when 'insanity ' and 'diminished responsibility' are juxtaposed to one another is that 'insanity' is extremely narrow in scope. It excludes any other form of mental aberration such as somnambulism, epilepsy, imbecility. The Scottish Law Commission suggests that it should be termed instead as "mental disorder" (1).
Author : elnora98

Related Essays

Legal Rights Before and After Arrest
What Constitutes Crime? Principle IV of the Principles of International Law recognized in the Charter of the Nurnberg Tribunal and in the Judgment of the Tribunal, 1950, states as follows: “the fact that a person acted pursuant to order of his government or of a superior does not relieve him from responsibility under international law, provided a moral choice was in fact possible to him” (Principles of International Law, 1950). In addition, Principle II of the same proclaims that even if the internal law does not punish a person, the person is still liable to be punished under...
7 pages (1757 words) Research Paper
The Rules Governing the Insanity Defence in Order to Determine When a Person Should Not Be Criminally Liable
The Rules Governing the Insanity Defence in Order to Determine When a Person Should Not Be Criminally Liable
14 pages (3514 words) Essay
insanity plea
Of importance to note is that, a person is liable to have committed crime when he or she has committed an illegal act, and or intended to commit an illegal act such as murder, stealing rape among other heinous acts (Anderson and Gardner 52). Simply, the issue of insanity does not revolve around the diagnosis that the accused undergoes but rather the impact that it might have caused on his or her ability to do specific things at the said time when there was an alleged criminal act. Hence, the Law stipulated that it is the relevant factor revolves around a person ability to do a specific thing...
5 pages (1255 words) Research Paper
Insanity vs Psychosis in a legal concept
Psychosis can also be associated with heavy drug abuse and drug use (Hirstein, 2009). Insanity on the other hand generally refers to the broad range of abnormal behavior and instability thereby making people think of it as closely linked or related to psychosis. Just as in psychosis, insanity is perceived as mental instability that makes people see things that are not real, and makes them think, behave, believe and act differently which manifest in behaviors that violates widely held social norms. These acts can collectively lead to endangering ones and others lives or may lead to one...
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
Criminal Law
Alan has a paranoid personality and is prone to depression. Betty is Alan's girlfriend. She is having an affair with Clive and does not conceal this fact form Alan who feels demeaned and angry. Betty comes home form the pub one day and announces to Alan that she is going to leave him for Clive. She packs her bags and goes. Not knowing what to do, Alan picks up a hunting rifle and goes in search of Clive. He looks through the pub window and sees both Betty and Clive together. Whilst taking aim at Clive with the rifle, Dennis, an old friend from the pub, staggers over Alan and gives him a hard...
7 pages (1757 words) Case Study
Mental Disorder and Criminal Justice System
It should be noted that the latter law was abolished during the nineteen sixties; however some individuals may still be liable to such conditions. (UK government, 2008)
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!