Insanity and Diminished Responsibility - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Insanity and Diminished Responsibility

abnormality of the mind ( R v Byrne ); drug personality disorder (Celebici Trial); involuntary intoxication ( R v Galbraith) ; mental weakness and low intelligence ( Lord Dea's decision ) ; minority ( R v Raven ); physical deformities such as blindness and being a deaf-mute ( R v Pritchard). In the treatise "Partial Defences To Murder" more mitigating factors are added i.e. sufficient provocation by the offended party ( R v Smith ); immediate vindication of a grave offence to himself or his relatives (Table 7); Incomplete self-defence where there is no reasonable necessity of the means employed by the culprit (R v Martin); passion or obfuscation (Case 113); disease or injury (Note 17); jealousy, mercy killing, depression, relationship of victim to the accused (Table 7). The list goes on and on.
Insanity is a plea or defence by which the accused at the time of the commission of the act, "was laboring under such a defect of reason, arising from a disease of the mind, as not to know the nature and quality of the act he was doing or, if he did know it, that he did not know that what he was doing was wrong (The M'Naghten Rules). Insanity totally exempts the culprit from criminal liability unless he does it during a lucid interval. If so, he is wholly liable for the crime unless there are mitigating factors attending the crime.
Diminished Respons ...Show more


The first thing one observes when 'insanity ' and 'diminished responsibility' are juxtaposed to one another is that 'insanity' is extremely narrow in scope. It excludes any other form of mental aberration such as somnambulism, epilepsy, imbecility. The Scottish Law Commission suggests that it should be termed instead as "mental disorder" (1).
Author : elnora98
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Insanity and Diminished Responsibility"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Legal Rights Before and After Arrest
The first problem, according to Rosiers and Bittle (2004) is that law does have a strong social basis. In other words, the law of a land is shaped by the ideals of the society in which it operates. As a result, new and new crimes appear in the statute books from time to time, and again, the law of a land gets significantly different from the law of another geographical area, and thirdly, though an action does not violate law in a particular country, if it violates the international law, the person again is liable to be punished.
7 pages (1750 words) Research Paper
The Rules Governing the Insanity Defence in Order to Determine When a Person Should Not Be Criminally Liable
The court found him insane whom in an assassination attempt to Robert Peel the British Prime Minister, mistakenly killed his secretary. This led to the formation of strictures whereby it was avowed that a defendant was required to have a mental condition or illness and even retardation that was required to be severe to an extent that the defendant had no insight as to the quality and nature of the act committed without the knowledge that the act was wrong.
14 pages (3500 words) Essay
Insanity plea
It is used by the criminal defendants where the accused must be absolutely impaired by a mental disease or defect at the time when a crime is committed to enable him or her receive such a defense (Torre 97). Actual Defense The insanity defense is one of the numerous misused features of the forensic psychiatry that does not only allow sane persons to impose ‘insanity traits’ in courts but it also allow to criminals or dangerous people to continue being in the society especially after they have undergone medical tests (Anderson and Gardner 50).
5 pages (1250 words) Research Paper
Insanity vs Psychosis in a legal concept
Psychosis is widely associated with two main symptoms which are hallucinations and delusions. In hallucinations people tend to hear, see and even in some cases smell things which are non-existent. Delusion on the other hand, is conditions where people believe things that when examined in rational manners are evidently false, for instance believing that your doctor is secretly planning to inject you with a kill substance.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Criminal Law
She packs her bags and goes. Not knowing what to do, Alan picks up a hunting rifle and goes in search of Clive. He looks through the pub window and sees both Betty and Clive together. Whilst taking aim at Clive with the rifle, Dennis, an old friend from the pub, staggers over Alan and gives him a hard slap on the back.
7 pages (1750 words) Case Study
Mental Disorder and Criminal Justice System
During the year 1999, the UK parliament passed the Criminal cases review Insanity Act in which the Court of Appeal has been granted the powers to be able to carry out a hearing and dismissals based on the guilty but insane Act whose reference dates back to the Criminal cases Review Commission.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Find out how much would it cost
to get a custom paper written by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email