StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Nuisance - Essay Example

Extract of sample

However in Hunter v. Canary Wharf the House of Lords stated that the distinction implied the creation of two separate torts.
The interference with use or enjoyment of land of claimant takes place through various ways, which includes adverse affect on negihour's sleep through vibrations and noises (Halsey v Esso Petroleum) and encroachment of roots (Solloway v. Hampshire CC) . The reasonableness of act is considered when determining on possibility of nuisance, so an action for nuisance may fail if found of reasonable use to the community and is of a temporary nature(Harrison v. Southwark). Reasonableness is dependent on variety of factors which include the duration of interference, sensitivity of the plaintiff, character of neighbor hood, and the defendant's fault.
Further the character of the neighbourhood may be a vital factor in case of interference with enjoyment or use. (Sturger v. Bridgman) However it is not important when physical damage to property is sustained. (St. Helens)
Finally the fault on the part of claimant can be found to be strict in certain situation while fault based in others. If it is found that the claimant continued the nuisance for example by annoying his neighbor through noises which are intolerable, then an injunction would be granted.(Christie v Davey)The traditional view has been to create a distinction between the creator of the nuisance (with strict liability) and one who carried on or adopted the nuisance (which is decided on the ground that whether the defendant knew or ought to have known of the nuisance) . By the case law it has been seen that the courts have ignored sensitivity issues when there is a strong possibility of malice.(Hollywood Fox v. Emmett).
The traditional position had been that only those having a legal interest could bring an action. However trespassers have been included. (Pemberton v. Sothwark)
The decision of the House of Lords in Hunter v. Canary Wharf is of significance because it scrupulously analyzed on the previous cases, upholding the traditional view. Lord Cooke argued that the right to sue could either be confined to those having an interest in the land or to those who live there; it entirely depended on the policy of law. Further Lord Goff stated that the current state of law could bring in certainty and efficacy. The decision of hunter can be considered to be an important aspect of looking at the interpretation given by the judges to develop the law. However it can be said that the dissenting opinion of Lord Cooke can be overridden by the fact that on follow up to ECHR it was found that all the applicants under hunter should be protected under Article 8 ECHR. Further it can be said that harassment an issue in Hunter can now be claimed under other heads rather than nuisance. (Khorasandjian v. Bush)In McKenna v British Aluminuim it was accepted that due to the Art8 claims based on property would be inappropriate. The development of the case law is therefore entirely dependent on the interpretation of judges of the Human Rights Act 1998.
The area of public nuisance has been said to be an unsatisfactory area covering loops of ...Show more


Nuisance being a separate tort in itself has been divided into public and private nuisance, the latter is defined as an unreasonable interference with the enjoyment of land or some other interest in relation to its enjoyment. The objective principle or "reasonable user principle" is the important basis of the tort.
Author : irunolfsson
Nuisance Essay essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Nuisance Essay"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

This paper evaluates a trespass case study. It also highlights the implications of trespass and merits of standard contract forms. Furthermore, it highlights a business operation case study. Question 1: At what point does a breach of planning control occur?
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Nuisance and Tresspass Law
The paper will dissect the nature and extent of these tortuous actions and the remedies available to both parties. Private nuisance is the form is the tort in which ones right in the enjoyment of property is interfered with. It can either take the form of invasion or withdrawal or both (LaMance, n.d).
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Nuisance and Tresspass
The house is located on Highfield Road opposite a factory unit (situated on Highfield Road in the Edward’s Industrial estate) owned by Harrington & Nephew Ltd. This is an area in which pre-cast concrete units are manufactured. Harrington & Nephew Ltd. was recently successful in winning various contracts which have resulted in the factory operating all day and throughout the night.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Environmental Nuisance Lawsuit
Chris is the Defendant and is represented by Kelly Greene, while Pat Calloway is representing NICE, the Plaintiff. Chris has agreed to testify on behalf of the defense, while Sam Anxious, the owner of an adjoining property to Northfield Farm is testifying on behalf of NICE.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Nuisance is of two kinds : Public nuisance is interference with the right of public in general and is punishable as an offense.: Obstructing a public way by digging a trench, or constructing structures on it are examples of public nuisance. Although such obstruction may cause inconvenience to many persons but none can be allowed to bring a civil action for that, otherwise there may be hundreds of actions for a.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Nuisance Case Law
Because of the various of history and the connection between the two forms, private nuisance has come to cover different types of conduct on the part of defendants. Indeed, beyond saying that all these instances are actionable because they are intolerable inconveniences, the only other common element is that they affect the claimants' use or enjoyment of their land.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Junk 'mail' - nuisance or opportunity
“Irrelevance remains a major problem…consumer feedback is plain: ‘Send me something I’m interested in, or shut up” (Thorpe, 2008, p.38). Junk mail
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Nuisance ( torts law)
Private nuisances entail harm to the lands of the complainant of his use of the ownership of such lands. Blackstone describes a private nuisance as "anything done to
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Attractive nuisance doctrine
to tort laws, the Attractive Nuisance Doctrine states that, people who own land may be held responsible for accidents that occur to children trespassing on the land (Okrent 22). This law applies if the risk is caused by dangerous objects, or some features of the lands that are
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment