StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Early interpretation of the commerce clause - Essay Example


Extract of sample
Early interpretation of the commerce clause

The commerce clause raises three major questions that can be satisfactorily answered by having a proper interpretation of the clause. These questions revolve around the meaning of “commerce", “among the several States” and “to regulate.” Interpretation here refers to the method of determining the meaning of the words included in the clause. At the time of its creation, the term commerce was used in the clause to mean trade or exchange of goods. It could also be expansively interpreted as any gainful activity. However, this excluded some gainful activities like manufacturing, agriculture and other methods of production. Barnett (2001) states that these exclusions were made because it was improper to have a congressional power that controlled agriculture with Indian Tribes and manufacturing with foreign nations. Under the constitution convention, it was agreed that the term commerce be used as a substitute for trade and exchange. Contextual analysis of the clause gives a strong support to a conclusion that the phrase “among several states” was initially used to refer to mean between persons of different states. However, this interpretation would render the term ‘among several states superfluous or excessive. According to Grant and Pushaw (1999), the reason for adding the term among several states ,and foreign nations, was to exclude some forms of commerce from the power of the congress.

Related Essays

Law of E-commerce
Taking electronic commerce (e-commerce) related initiatives, the European Union (EU) aimed at boosting the Union’s economic prospects, improving its competitiveness and facilitating its progressive adaptability to the digital era (Hornle, 2000). Under the administrative guidance of the Lisbon European Council, EU commission drafted comprehensive ‘e-Europe Action Plan in March 2000-recommenadtions which were endorsed months later at the Feira European Council (Hartmann, 2006).
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
The Interpretation of Umbrella Clause in Investment Treaties
al risks in order to obtain protection for investment.3 In fact, there are different standards of protection which BITs usually include some of them, as in the case of fair and equitable treatment, full protection and security, most favoured nation treatment and umbrella clause.
16 pages (4000 words) Essay
Critically Analyse the Interpretation of Umbrella Clause in Investment Treaties
Foreign investments take a much longer time to develop before they achieve peak efficiency and generate regular financial returns. In addition to this, foreign investments are crucial to the economic progress of developing countries, supplying the needed capital, technology, entrepreneurial know-how, and infrastructure to the host country.1 Because foreign investments are so important to their economy, host countries have a tendency to interfere even in commercial contracts between foreign investors and host country counterparts.2 For this reason, legal devices in the form of clauses in contracts and treaties have been resorted to in order to afford some measure of protection for the foreign
14 pages (3500 words) Essay
Such trends are however established by collective impacts from individual members of the society. Political environments also identify collective positions that are sometimes so intense to determine people’s behaviors at personal levels. The greatest sense in the phrase is however noted in social set-ups in which culture and traditional beliefs are significant in people’s lives.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
International Commerce
Thus, party autonomy is recognized as one of the cardinal elements of international commercial arbitration.This past decade has witnessed an expansion in the scope of arbitrable matters. This trend is exemplified by Mitsubishi Motors Corp. v. Soler 1 in which the United States Supreme Court held that antitrust disputes arising from international contracts are arbitrable.
35 pages (8750 words) Essay
E-commerce law
The definition of electronic commerce can be found in Internet Tax Freedom Act as “any transaction conducted over the Internet or through Internet access, comprising the sale, lease,
24 pages (6000 words) Essay
Exclusion clause
Exclusion clauses are common in business contracts in which settlements of liability are unreasonable and would otherwise threaten the financial assets. Contracts with exclusion clauses require the offeree to understand the terms
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Was the Commerce Clause portion of National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius correctly decided
Al, 1). This clause in other words, wants individuals who do not have insurance covers from their employers or from the government to seek insurance covers from private insurance companies.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Cosmopolitanism, according to the reading, implies the idea that human beings, Japanese in this scenario, originated from a common
2 pages (500 words) Essay


The commerce clause raises three major questions that can be satisfactorily answered by having a proper interpretation of the clause. These questions revolve around the meaning of “commerce", “among the several States” and “to regulate.” …
Author : zschmeler
Early interpretation of the commerce clause essay example
Read Text Preview
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation