case studies - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
case studies

One of the most significant law of tort cases in the US is the Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Co., 248 N.Y. 339, 162 N.E. 99 (N.Y. 1928). The case can aptly be described as significant since its effects shaped and established the concepts of the scope of business liability, the relevance of proximate cause and the limits of negligence.
At the heart of the case is Mrs. Helen Palsgraf who was waiting on a Long Island Railway train platform, until two men approached running after a train. As a security officer helped one of the men get on board, the man dropped his package. Since this luggage contained explosives, an explosion of a very powerful scale resulted there-from. This resulted in Palsgraf’s injury. Mrs. Palsgraf entered a personal injury lawsuit against the company, Long Island Railroad. The two main issues that emerged from the case are: the manner of determination of the duty of care; and the person to whom the party owes its duty of due care.
In this case, the Court of Appeals ruled against the favor of Mrs. Palsgraf. The court maintained that there was no direct relationship between the guard’s action (of pulling the second passenger on board) and Palsgraf’s injury. The crux of the matter is that there has to be a direct nexus between the guard’s action and Mrs. Palsgraf’s injury, in order for liability to be cited. The Senior Judge Benjamin Cardozo, while writing for the three-judge bench, maintained that the guard in no way was aware of the presence of the explosion in the package. Therefore, by shoving the passenger inside, he was not aware that an explosion would ensue.
Cardozo continued that even the most cautious mind could not guess the presence of danger in the package. Moreover, there was no way the soldier’s action of pushing the passenger into the train directly affected Mrs. Palsgraf. ...
Download paper


Tort law exists to ensure that businesses and entrepreneurial undertakings are exacted within the provisions of the law and that fraud, debauchery and breach of contract are kept under, in the business world. Given the competitive nature of businesses and the desire to actualize…
Author : lednerhershel

Related Essays

Case Study-Ethical Decisions
Thus, the benefits of taking a decision to release inmates for community-based work on the ground of security guess work are plenty. First of all, it satisfies the existing security officers as they feel that William can protect their security and dignity. That means they will not take unnecessary leaves because of the perceived threat for their lives; firstly, due to the reduced inmate population and, secondly, due to th.
10 pages (2510 words) Case Study
case of Vasiliy Gorshkov and Alexey Ivano
There are readily available hacker tools that can be used by unskilled people to wreak havoc for financial gain or just for fun. The disturbing reality is that many people are not aware they are actually committing a crime until it is too late. This has been a serious problem for teachers, parents, governments and businesses trying to work hard to protect children and the general public from online threats. The best way to protect people from computer crime is by letting them understand what computer crime is all about. Computer crime can be viewed in three ways. The first one is attacking...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Latham's Australian Immigration Policy and Horne's The Lucky Country are examples of primary documents that may be used for this objective. This paper summarizes each document first, then tackles them both in an integrated section, and finally makes a conclusion.
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
case studies College Case Study
(citation omitted but mentioned in this case)
8 pages (2008 words) Case Study
Paralegal studies
l level between the two of them and explain to him that her response is not on behalf of the firm and in the event of any arising matter then both the firm and she would not be responsible nor liable. If however the policies set by the firm to guide paralegals is against that then she should completely restrain from responding to Larry though explain to her in a professional and friendly way that would not make the firm lose her as a client.
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Business case studies
Specific performance may therefore be granted in the event that the court can identify the elements and that no vitiating factor exists in a case. Further, in case of existence of a vitiating factor, the party with an advantage over the factors must have not rescinded the contract of must not have such intentions. An agreement between the two parties, consideration, contractual capacity, and legality of the subject matter must be met and the process of creating the contract must be free from duress, undue influence, misrepresentation, and fraud (Goldman and Sigismond 129). In addition to...
4 pages (1004 words) Case Study
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!