StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Medical Ethics and Informed Consent - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
Your F. Name 3 November 2012 The Willowbrook Letters The issue of the research was to infect students at a school for retarded children with hepatitis as an experiment. Many editorials published this information recognizing the researcher for his line of work at the Willowbrook State School but not acknowledging that there was a possible ethic problem with this type of experiment, treating the retarded children merely as lab rats rather than as people…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
Medical Ethics and Informed Consent
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Medical Ethics and Informed Consent"

Download file to see previous pages

Researchers argued that the experimentation was to help develop an immunization for hepatitis B. The ethical challenges at hand are that yes, it is evident that research needed to be done on hepatitis at that time. However, children with mental retardation already have problems enough in their lives. This is like saying that their life has no value. In some cases, the parents did not consent. Depending on the level of mental retardation, a child can thrive but to deliberately expose them to hepatitis could greatly diminish their already lowered quality of life and the children have no say in it.

They are the ones to go through the pain and struggle but instead were treated as though they were already discarded bodies. For the parents that may have consented to this experiment, they were subjecting their children to something that the effects were unknown. During a type of experiment like this, it is questionable as to what informed consent even is because what are the minimum standards for subjecting a person’s life to something that could be fatal for the sake of the medical industry?

It could almost be envisioned as child abuse. Neither the researchers nor the publishing journals were responsible in making their decision to infect these children. It could be argued whether or not the publication of these editorials was ethical as well. The information about the research was disclosed that the children were at a particular school and that is an issue of confidentiality. Additionally, it was an experiment conducted on human beings. No one was to know the outcome. To publish the editorials was almost an intent to show that there was controversy in the medical field and to create a media inspired uproar.

Abigail Alliance vs. FDA Majority Opinion Abigail was a terminally ill patient with cancer whom had undergone chemotherapy and radiation. She also had possible access to experimental drugs that her oncologist was suggesting. Though she could have possibly had positive effects and saved her life, the drug was only available for clinical trials. By the time that she was allowed to be entered into the clinical trial program, she was too ill to make the trip to see if the drugs would work on her and she died a couple of weeks later.

The Abigail Alliance was created to help expand the availability for drugs that are only available for clinical trials to also be available to patients that are terminally ill. These drugs not only could have been helpful for Abigail but for many other patients just like her that were minimally competent and would have had the ability to make the decision for themselves had the FDA not stood in their way of obtaining these drugs. The FDA, though it makes regulations about drugs in the United States, has to conduct research on these pharmaceuticals to test to ensure that they are safe.

For someone that is terminally ill, it could be a method of helping to create a better quality of life or even improve their longevity. These patients were not given the right to access treatment but the FDA looks at it from the perspective of being a liability if their organization allows just anyone to take these drugs

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Medical Ethics and Informed Consent Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Medical Ethics and Informed Consent Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1460284-medical-ethics-and-informed-consent
(Medical Ethics and Informed Consent Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Medical Ethics and Informed Consent Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1460284-medical-ethics-and-informed-consent.
“Medical Ethics and Informed Consent Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1460284-medical-ethics-and-informed-consent.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Medical Ethics and Informed Consent

Medical Law and Ethics

The case study "Medical Law and Ethics" points out that informed consent for neonates, children, and young people has been a subject of intense research in recent times (3, 4, 18, 19).... One among such guidelines is the informed consent (IC).... Surgery performed by a junior doctor in the absence of a supervising senior doctor and without the informed consent of the dead patient.... An evergreen debate in Medical Law and Ethics concerns 'informed consent' (IC)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Law and Ethics of Consent from Children in Medicine

However, whenever the minor is considered incompetent, the informed consent is required from the parents.... When ever providing consent for medical treatment, according to the age of the child there is a variance of treatment.... The Family Reform Act of 1969 provides that, ”the consent to treatment of a 16 or 17 year old is to be treated like the consent of an adult”( FRA 1969).... hellip; Minors in some places are deemed incompetent and are not given the right to consent....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Medicine and Capital Punishment

This paper ''Biomedical ethics'' tells that The medical profession is a science not only regulated by policies but also of moral imperatives in healthcare management.... medical practitioners remained ascribed with rules that limit their actions and interventions with patients.... hellip; In this paper, the researcher is challenged to explore the correlation of the medical profession with ethical concerns viz-a-viz issues relating to chemical castration to capital punishment....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Medical Ethics and the Legal Framework: Chester versus Afshar the English Tort Law Cases

Legal implications are bound to follow… It is in this line that this excerpt looks to evaluate medical cases and extensively on confidentiality and informed consent prior to treatment or medical procedure. The Moral capability must never be inferred culpability Such an individual whose sole field of training is entirely concentrated with treatment or diagnosis may not easily possess or acquire interpersonal and conceptual skills demanded by consent.... This paper will explore what lies behind informed consent versus disclosure and the terms governing it directed by medical ethics and the legal framework....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Context of Consent

In the present-day context, consent is believed to foster patient-practitioner relationship and asserted to be in accordance with medical ethics.... The paper "The Context of consent" states that the practitioner is considered negligent if he/she fails to provide complete information to the patient, especially the risk involved before receiving consent.... In other words, to ensure patients are benefited from the treatment and no harm is brought upon them, either in physical or psychological terms, the practitioner should obtain the consent of the patient....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

Ethical Principles of an Informed Consent

The informed consent in general has two aspects, the informed consent for medical treatment and informed consent for medical research.... One such thing that has become a buzz word of ethical standard in both medical practice and research is “informed consent”.... (Beauchamp &Childress, 1989)informed consent:informed consent can be described as an agreement given by the patient for a proposed course of treatment or a research activity, upon receiving clear, understandable information about the ensuing potential benefits and risks....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Ethical Principles Underlying a Particular Aspect of the Informed Consent

'Informed consent is an ethical concept that has become an integral to contemporary medical ethics and medical practice, it ensures protection of patients against unwanted medical treatment, but it also makes possible of active involvement of the patient in her medical planning and care.... Awareness of the outcomes of the suggested action is given in a fully informed consent to patients in order for them to understand the possibility of reasonable risks, and for them to make a choice from all possible alternatives which are available to them....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Ethics and Law Subject: Consent to Treatment

Ethics has come to be a major factor to consider in the creation, use, and management of patient records, valid and informed consent in treatment amongst other medical-related support.... The following assessment paper will assess the ethical challenges associated with valid and informed consent to treatment and to the creation, use, and management of patient records, consent forms, and associated health information to support care and treatment.... One of the major issues which have continuously generated a lot of attention in the medical world is a function of informed consent and the protection and promotion of individual autonomy....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us