StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Positivism - Essay Example

Extract of sample

Legal systems are not static, immutable structures but rather mutable, and ever-changing organisms. The fact that they are constantly changing means that some constancy as regards to the need to obey the "rules" of a legal system is needed. Otherwise there is chaos.
The apparent paradox within the idea that "the mere fact that a rule is just or reasonable will not make it a law" and also, "nor does the injustice of a rule demonstrate that it is not a law" is in fact satisfied by an understanding that laws are, by their nature, limited in scope. Laws cover a finite number of situations whereas the experience of life for the series of individual human beings that make up a society is infinite. Thus it might well be "just" and/or "reasonable" to have a rule that people should be "kind to one another", but this will not make such a law feasible. Conversely, a rule that says that people of different races cannot marry (as occurred in the US South) is not made invalid as a law just because it is unjust. The morality (or otherwise) of a rule is, within the positivist sense, irrelevant to whether or not it is a law. It is a law because it is held within a complex legal structure that defines it as "law".
If laws are essentially arbitrary in nature, why should citizens of ...
The citizen gives up his "freedom" to do whatever he wants, and thus to break certain laws, in exchange for the government's promise to protect his/her safety. Thus a citizen stops at a red light - thus giving up his innate "freedom" to pass through it - in exchange for the government enforcing red light laws that will enable him to safely drive down the street when the light turns green.
This is a very 'modern' theory of obedience to rules and laws, based as it is upon the idea that the government and its people have essentially mutual interests. Within Rousseau's vision, the State clearly exists to serve the People. Some earlier theories of jurisprudence relied upon more authoritarian principles of law obedience that, despite their age, still have relevance today. John Austin, with his The Province of Jurisprudence Determined (1832) suggested the idea of "habitual obedience", that is obedience given to a sovereign (or perhaps elected government) based upon a fear of sanctions. Crudely, people obey the law because they fear the consequences if they do not.
On a superficial level Austin's ideas seem self-evident: people do avoid breaking the law because of the consequences if they do on an individual level. However, if a whole system of laws is based solely (or nearly completely) on "habitual obedience" then it is by nature fragile and ripe for change. A frightened people has no loyalty to the system of laws other than that which is forced upon them. If they get the chance to successfully rise up, or if another member of the ruling class sees a chance at taking over, then it is likely to occur. Habitual obedience occurs within totalitarian states and dictatorships, but these are often short-lived, while superficially ...Show more


Positivists claim that the legal validity of a rule is a matter of that rule's derivability from some basic conventional criterion of legal validity accepted in the particular legal system in question . . . The mere fact that a rule is just or reasonable will not make it a law; nor does the injustice of a rule demonstrate that it is not a law."
Author : sydneezboncak
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Positivism as an Epistemological System
According to the report positivism is considered to be an epistemological system through its advocacy of attaining empirical knowledge through sense perception, and its adherence to the scientific method i.e. induction. Positivist thought served as a foundation for the sciences. For instance, the influence of positivism grew ever more “in the social sciences, i.e. biology, psychology and linguistics.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Jurisprudence: Positivism and the Tradition of Austin
This paper will attempt to explain the philosophy of Hart, contrasted with the philosophies of Bentham and Austin, along with the critiques of Hart, then attempt to reach a conclusion as to whether Hart’s philosophy is as flawed as Bentham and Austin’s, or if Hart’s philosophy is grounded on a sounder basis than the philosophies of these two men.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Positivism and Social Constructionism
Along with the gradual changes in the society, Europeans became more aggressive in studying the evolving knowledge and ideas of man. In this paper, two main popular ideas that can became known throughout Europe and gained a larger number of supporters will be discuss: positivism and social constructionism.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Natural law and positivism
Natural laws are not necessarily written and they are considered superior to positive law. Positive laws are those laws that have been enacted by the proper authorities for the government of a society (1998). Positivism actually looks at what positive law is.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Positivism and Interpretivism
The following is an analysis of the similarities and differences between epistemology and ontology on the basis of positivism and interpretivism. To begin with, it is important to understand the concepts of positivism and interpretivism as the basis of epistemology and ontology.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Legal positivism
through positivistic jurisprudence from John Austin to H. L. A. Hart.6 The positivist discretion thesis has, however, been challenged by theorists like Ronald Dworkin, Rolf Sartorius and others.7 This paper explores the arguments of both the positivist and non-positivist camps and discusses whether an acceptance of the positivist thesis will cause one to adopt a different outlook with regards to the judicial process in hard cases.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Explaining Crime: Classicism and Positivism
It can affect the victim's self-esteem to the point that he or she starts thinking of themselves as worthless. It is one of most prevailing type of violence world-wide. In the United Kingdom, around quarter of all reported violent crimes are domestic and in the United States the approximate number of incidents of domestic violence varies from 960,000 incidents to four million each year (Curtis 2004).
14 pages (3500 words) Essay
Natural Law and Legal Positivism
The theory defines law as rules made by human beings whether deliberately or unintentionally, and that, these laws must be submissive to the rules of determinism. In this paper, I will describe ethical positivism as an alternative to the natural law and legal positivism.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
These problems were most evident in the legal systems of eighteenth century Europe. The classical criminology approach defined both a motive behind committing a crime, and methods for its control, and was an improvement of the justice system from the harsh and unlawful
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Positivism-the key to success
If a person is positive about something in one’s life, one is sure to succeed in that endeavor or vocation. Happiness depends a
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Let us find you another Essay on topic Positivism for FREE!
Contact us:
Contact Us Now
FREE Mobile Apps:
  • About StudentShare
  • Testimonials
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Free Essays
  • New Essays
  • Essays
  • The Newest Essay Topics
Join us:
Contact Us