Hume's Posteriori Argument against Miracles Is not Valid - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Hume's Posteriori Argument against Miracles Is not Valid

The ‘a posteriori argument’ states that even if miracles were a possibility according to evidence, they in fact, have never occurred (Johnson & Anthony, 72). Hume’s ‘a posteriori argument’ has some merit from a general perspective, they are problematic from the perspective of an individual miracle test-case, i.e., the alleged resurrection of Jesus. I will argue that although the first of Hume’s three ‘a posteriori argument’s succeeds in showing that there may be no miracle proofs, it doesn’t show that there is not a sufficient probability for establishing our test case. Anti-Thesis In his first argument from a posteriori considerations, Hume sets out the qualitative requirements of a proof and a successful probability for a miracle along with the quantitative requirements of a miracle proof, and he argues for the (implied) thesis that the quantitative requirements of a proof have not been satisfied (Hume, Enquiry, 116-117). For Hume, the following qualitative conditions are required for a good individual miracle-testimony: the witness must be highly educated, socially outstanding, patently honest, have lots to lose by lying, and be situated in such circumstances that, if lying, exposure would readily result. ...Show more


[Author’s Name] Hume’s Posteriori Argument against Miracles is not Valid Introduction In this essay “On Miracles,” Hume argues against the miraculous (Mossner 64). His argument is divided into two parts, his a priori (before the experience) argument of part I, and his a posteriori (after the experience) argument of part II…
Author : nmraz
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Hume's Posteriori Argument against Miracles Is not Valid "
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Hume's Philosophy about reason and Passion
He argued that nevertheless reason is very useful & it leads us to the judgment between good & evil, but when it comes to motivation it is the passion which leads & the reason behaves like a slave of it. Human emotions are not subjected to reasons & they are stronger than logics & previously defined ethics.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Virtues a successful ruler has according to Machiavelli
The human race has always shown a tendency to elect a leader whenever they come together as one big social group. There are privileges that come with this position as a way of showing gratitude to the elected person. Since it is human nature to feel powerful and above others in his surrounding, people strive to achieve that status quo.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
A few challenges include research activities. Research will affirm or negate a research question. Research includes gathering evidences to accept or reject a hypothesis. My current research challenge will result to proving that God exists, using cosmological argument.
3 pages (750 words) Admission/Application Essay
hich we must deduct whether a miracle has taken place is higher than it is the case of other cases asserting to identify some extraordinary or unanticipated occurrence. It is consequently not a miracle if a healthy person in unlikely events dies. Though an occurrence of this form may be impractical, it does not sometimes take place.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Against Method. Is the approach to science a valid form of inquiry?
Concerning falsifications and contemporary scientific theories he highlights that there are often many inconsistent observations witnessed. This text assesses the deficiencies of numerous widespread notions concerning scientific development and the nature of knowledge.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
The problem of mind and body exists primarily because humans naturally desire to place the mental experience of conscious organisms into the organic and scientific categories in which other elements are held. Therein exists a dilemma; it is apparent that all we do is determined and controlled by the mind; however, it would require defining features of the psychological condition that are not explicable on the basis of the human physical operations.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Compare David Hume's ideas
His main area of interest in philosophy was on “The Origin of Our Ideas and Skepticism about Causal Reasoning.” His emphasis was on the difference between impression and thoughts or ideas, which are the two basic categories of the human mind perception (Hume 120).
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Assess Hume's Contribution To The Philosophy Of Religion
(The most fascinating area of philosophy that questions about the existence of God-the standard arguments whether there is a God through the point of miracles-Hume's point of view on miracles-Pascal's wager versus Hume's theory that religious belief depends on psychological and sociological factors, Ontological argument vs.
4 pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review
Secularism in the Renaissance
This new outlook in intellectual Renaissance in Italy, which basically maintained that religion should not get in the way of living life to its fullest, was best reflected by the works of Nicolo Machiavelli (1469-1527), most importantly his celebrated political treatise The Prince.
3 pages (750 words) Admission/Application Essay
Ethical objectivism and Kantian Ethics ar arguments to ethical relativism
One considers one of the most prominent example the cultural actions of the Nazi’s in carrying out the Holocaust in World War II; few would condone such an action based on cultural relativism.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Philosophy/ book review/critique
It was in the mid-twentieth century that the process of democratization of the world got noticeably accelerated and it is in this context that the Third World
5 pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review
Morality based on consequences (like utilitarianism) or morality based on duties
Further, the Kants ethics perspective holds that it is not the consequence of an action that makes it either right or wrong, but the motive behind the action being taken (Vaughn, 2012). Thus,
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Find out how much would it cost
to get a custom paper written by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email