StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu
  • Home
  • Subjects
  • Philosophy
  • Assess and arguments for the law of karma, and discuss whether the law implies or refutes the ex

Assess and arguments for the law of karma, and discuss whether the law implies or refutes the ex - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Assess and arguments for the law of karma, and discuss whether the law implies or refutes the ex

Sankhya believe that the material of creation is made of earth and stone and could possibly not be created by ‘Isvara’ whose own characteristics are not consistent with the same material (Radhakrishnan 43 b). The Sankhya doctrine holds that it is not possible to prove the existence of God and therefore he cannot be said to exist (Larson 83). I would opine that the doctrine contention aligns with the view that a benevolent God would have no motive of creating a world of mixed happiness and sorrows. The Purusa takes an important place in the understanding of the Sankhya doctrine. The Sankhya offers that the Purusa is not caused (Collins 106). The Purusa is usually likened to consciousness. In most doctrines, consciousness is usually attached to the idea of the existence of a Supreme being. The Sankhya position that the Purusa is not caused directly contradicts the idea of the existence of a creator God. However, problems arise within the doctrine with the supposition that Purusa does not have any qualities. In my opinion, this view would imply that all beings are same. Such a thesis would refute the possibility of the existence of different fates for different actions as understood within the overall framework of the Karma. The position adds weight to some of the problems and contradictions that have been identified within the Sankhya doctrine with regard to the nature and qualities of the Purusa. The character of the ‘Isvara’ according to the doctrine developed by the Sankhya is that he is not attached to the universe (Radhakrishnan 40 b). According to the Mimamsa doctrine, the ‘Isvara’ does not provide the fruits of actions, which essentially distinguishes them from other doctrines that assign roles of reward and punishment to the deity (Radhakrishnan 22 b). Instead, the rewards or consequences of actions are purely depended on the actions of individuals. Good actions beget positive consequences, while bad actions bring about negative consequences. The Mimamsa doctrine does not mention whether or not the ‘Isvara’ created the universe (Radhakrishnan 19 b). In my view, I would conclude that the positions adopted by both doctrines acknowledge the fact of divine being but do not agree on his nature or tasks. In general terms, the Sankhya philosophy is governed by the concept of dualism. The philosophy challenges the view of the God as central idea that controls the cause and destiny of humanity. The destiny of man, according to Mimamsa is dependent on the actions and will of man in accordance with the Verdas (Radhakrishnan 74 a). In this sense, God is only a benevolent power that grants to human beings their due share in accordance with their character on earth. It is therefore important to consider the fact that the actions of man are integral in the destiny of the universe. The cultivation of ‘Dama’ or self-control as a way of pursuing a virtuous and upright life (Radhakrishnan 13 b). Samkhya adopts the position that the harmony in the world is born out of the paradoxical dualities as argued by Sage Kapila. Samkhya philosophy is founded on the idea of harmony numerals. According to the terms of this philosophy the collection of elements and characteristics of things in the universe work to maintain some sense of balance between the systems. The underlying meaning in the Samkhya philosoph ...Show more

Summary

Name: Natasha Neehaul Course: MA Indian Philosophy Course Instructor: Dr Will Rasmussen Date: 14/12/12 Assess Sa?khya’s and Mima?sa’s arguments for the law of karma, and discuss whether the law implies or refutes the existence of God. Sankhya and Mimamsakas have various convergence and divergent points with regard to the Karma and its perspectives on the existence of God…
Author : ureichel
Assess and arguments for the law of karma, and discuss whether the law implies or refutes the ex essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Assess and arguments for the law of karma, and discuss whether the law implies or refutes the ex"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Discuss the ways in which law is changed and assess whether the law responds adequately to changes in technology and changes in
English Legal System English law is made up of six main sources (Winfield, 2000 p158). They are Common Law Equity Statutes Judicial Precedence (Jurisprudence) European Law & International Treaties and Laws Common Law refers to the consolidation of various legal codes and systems unique to various parts of Britain after the Norman's conquest.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Karma
According to Danny many people believe that karma is the only just action in the whole universe (34). However, some people do not believe in the existence of karma, and they believe their deeds are only judged by a deity. The original concept of karma was developed in India.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Law
Secondly, the study seeks to find out whether legal origin and shareholder protection are associated in any way, and whether countries with the common law origin show signs of robust development of the stock market, compared with countries that mainly apply civil law.
17 pages (4250 words) Essay
Law
I conducted further research on the Incorporated Council of law reporting for England and Wales only to find that it has been in existence since 1865 and prove to be an authority on both law and its accurate reporting. The fact that the Council operated as a charity served to further convince me of its dedication to accurate reporting and its commitment to do with no consideration for financial gain.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Law
545). In this way national courts are able to assist in the enforcement of EC law, since a ruling may indicate either that the Member State is in breach of Community law through a national law or procedure or even that a provision of EC regulations, directives or decision is
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
LAW OF EUROPEAN UNION. Discuss, with references to relevant EC Treaty provisions and decided cases, whether or not a reference should be made in this case, and
These developments are the concept of “acte clair” and the ECJ’s ruling in Folgia v Novello. The following discussion examines these developments in the context of Jane’s particular problem and expalins
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
LAW
It has, in turn, several elements specifically offer and acceptance. Consideration is the price or amount, in money or in kind, involve in the agreement. The intention to create legal relations simply means that
14 pages (3500 words) Essay
Discuss the ways in which law is changed and assess whether the law responds adequately to changes in technology and changes in social attitudes and expectations
Common Law refers to the consolidation of various legal codes and systems unique to various parts of Britain after the Normans conquest. It draws on the dominant morals, ethics and values to establish rules that are
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Critically evaluate the tests for certainty of objects in the law of trusts and assess whether developments in the last half century have had a positive or negative impact on the law
The objects of a trust are people who profit from the trust also referred to as beneficiaries. Additionally, the certainty of objects also refers to the resolutions for which the dependence has been affirmed. The benefactors of a trust must
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Can it be argued that all societies have law Critically discuss Anthropological arguments on the topic
In the very early years, the topic of anthropology was debated but one view that seemed to be widely accepted asserted that cultures normally evolve progressively and uniformly. Many of the anthropology scholars borrowed a leaf Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation