Assess and arguments for the law of karma, and discuss whether the law implies or refutes the ex

Assess and arguments for the law of karma, and discuss whether the law implies or refutes the ex Essay example
Masters
Essay
Philosophy
Pages 8 (2008 words)
Download 0
Name: Natasha Neehaul Course: MA Indian Philosophy Course Instructor: Dr Will Rasmussen Date: 14/12/12 Assess Sa?khya’s and Mima?sa’s arguments for the law of karma, and discuss whether the law implies or refutes the existence of God. Sankhya and Mimamsakas have various convergence and divergent points with regard to the Karma and its perspectives on the existence of God…

Introduction

Sankhya believe that the material of creation is made of earth and stone and could possibly not be created by ‘Isvara’ whose own characteristics are not consistent with the same material (Radhakrishnan 43 b). The Sankhya doctrine holds that it is not possible to prove the existence of God and therefore he cannot be said to exist (Larson 83). I would opine that the doctrine contention aligns with the view that a benevolent God would have no motive of creating a world of mixed happiness and sorrows. The Purusa takes an important place in the understanding of the Sankhya doctrine. The Sankhya offers that the Purusa is not caused (Collins 106). The Purusa is usually likened to consciousness. In most doctrines, consciousness is usually attached to the idea of the existence of a Supreme being. The Sankhya position that the Purusa is not caused directly contradicts the idea of the existence of a creator God. However, problems arise within the doctrine with the supposition that Purusa does not have any qualities. In my opinion, this view would imply that all beings are same. Such a thesis would refute the possibility of the existence of different fates for different actions as understood within the overall framework of the Karma. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related papers

Karma in Buddhism: Not Fate but an Act of Volition.
at the bottom of the hierarchy (Tola and Dragonetti 2009, p. 8). …
Discuss Whether Justified True Belief Can Be Considered Knowledge
Nonetheless, such engagement can also bring one to learn more about knowledge – a term ordinarily thought synonymous with the word ‘know’, when not everything we know constitutes knowledge, not even a JTB? JTB is composed of three concepts – belief, truth and justifiedness. Most basic of which is the understanding of belief, as the question of knowledge here is actually related with…
Whether an Officer should turn in one of his/her Marines for a minor fracture of the law or should they take matters into their own hands?
One of the most critical issues when evaluating the conditions of a particular case is to check whether a solution is more appropriate compared to another one, meaning that there are two options available. Such dilemma is common in the case of public services, where the following problem often appears: when an illegal activity takes place, the supervisor has the power to check the issue himself,…
The Fugitive Slave Law
The rights of the citizen especially freedom should be upheld by such legislation in Massachusetts. However, there is higher prevalence of slavery ever since the beginning of the 19th century. The law is supreme and south Massachusetts is a free state. As a citizen, human being and a free member of the American society, just like Jim, therefore, has a right to fare trial and treatment as a human…
Assess the role of law, and determine its importance,compare key arguements in the writting of thomass hobbes and john locke..
It is the contrasts observable in the philosophical arguments that form the basis of this analytical essay on the importance and role of law, with a view to reaching a credible conclusion. Introduction The concept of the role of law has been presented differently by different scholars. While there is a general agreement on the role and importance of law in the society, the philosophy behind this…
Platonian Law
This particular dialogue, for greater part in history, had been neglected as opposed to Plato's monumental Republic. He uses the imaginary city of Magnesia to create an ideal city-state and establish an ideal political and judicial structure in the city. 1…
Philosophy of Law
"What philosophy is, or should be, is itself a philosophical question that philosophers have understood and treated differently through the ages." (Wikipedia Philosophy p1). Philosophy can also be defined as a "doctrine: a belief (or system of beliefs) accepted as authoritative by some group or school; the rational investigation of questions about existence and knowledge and ethics; any personal…