ethical dilemma, analysing the dilemma using different ethical theories (utilitarianizm, liberty, virtue)

ethical dilemma, analysing the dilemma using different ethical theories (utilitarianizm, liberty, virtue) Essay example
Masters
Essay
Philosophy
Pages 5 (1255 words)
Download 0
Utilitarian, Virtue and Libertarian Approaches to Conjoined Twins Case Name Institution Date The present essay will explore the meaning and different concepts of ethical practice. Focusing on a case scenario, different theories of ethics will be outlined. The first section will expose the chosen ethical dilemma and describe the moral complexity of decision making…

Introduction

According to Catherine Berglund (2007) ethics is “a process of reflection”. Reflecting on what is right and what seems to be wrong. Arguments are looked at and analysed in order to come to a conclusion. It is due to medical ethics, that the right to consent and confidentiality have been identified (Holland, 2007). Ethical decisions are made every day, by every person. Is it right to park on disabled parking space when you rushing your child to the hospital? Or, is it fair to lie to your partner even if you know that it would make him happy? This is just the tip of the moral dilemmas’ iceberg. In December 2011 the conjoined twins Jesus and Emmanuel were born in Brazil; each one have their own head, brain, nervous system, and spine. They share heart, lungs, liver and all lower body organs. Few days before their birth Chilean conjoined twins Maria Paz and Maria Jose were separated followed by the death one of the girl a week later. The question is, should the conjoined twins be separated? Utilitarianism refers to the ethical theory, which postulates that taking an appropriate course of action increases the chances of perfection (Manuel, Claire, Shanks & Meyer, 2011). Its moral worthiness is based on the consequences of actions (Rawls, 2011). Proponents of this theory are J.S. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related papers

The Ethical Dilemma of Maximizing Pleasure. Utilitarianism Dilemma.
My predicament provides quite a simplified and inaccurate version of John Stuart Mill’s principle of utility which states that actions promoting happiness or pleasure are considered to be correct whereas actions promoting unhappiness or pain are considered to be wrong (John Stuart Mill 330). According to Mill’s principle, my choice of going to Nuit Blanche instead of studying was the right one…
Ethical Consideration of Using Nuclear Weapons
64-67). Discussion As mentioned earlier, it was during August 1945 that the world witnessed how destructive and horrendous are impacts of a nuclear bomb but the “nuclear weapons age” formally began a month later from this event on July 16, 1945 at 5:29am. The scientists chose a quite area of the New Mexico desert and that place of the experiment is now known as Jornado de Muerto (Journey of…
Ethical Dilemma of Illegal Immigrant Seeking Treatment
However, the car did not stop after the hit and as a result Santana was forced to run to the nearest emergency department despite the deep pain he was in. The medical history of the patient reveals that he has no health insurance. Furthermore, the patient is one of the undocumented immigrants from Mexico who has stayed in America for three years. With notable hesitation Santana explains to the…
Consent: A Philosophical Dilemma
In this article, I provide reasons to support O’Neill’s argument regarding the validity of consent as the fundamental principle in dealing with others. First, I evaluate the moral dimensions of treating others as they would like. Secondly, I address the validity of consent in justifying the way others are treated, thirdly I address the issue of hypothetical consent and moral actions, fourth, I…
Business Ethics Analytical Essay on a Ethical Dilemma
The dilemma of the situation is that you cannot choose both alternatives but you have to pick between the two alternatives (Badaracco, 1997). As a department manager, I have to choose between my integrity as a person and as a manager committed to do responsibilities and duties or choose to keep our productivity up and allow the bribes, dishonesties and lies that my employees do just to make close…
Philosophy Ethical Theories
It has been claimed by animal liberationists that animals should be deemed as persons and their legal rights as equals should be legislated. Equality to animals does no assert that animals possess the same characteristics as human beings or have the same needs; rather, it is focused on the equality of consideration. It is not a question of facts but that of morality as it is our moral obligation…
Normative Ethical Theories
Firstly, it is necessary to define and interpret the true nature and meaning of the deontological perspective as a means to adequately provide a normative interpretation of FGM. A deontological approach merely specifies that the end ethical consideration of a given action or decision must necessarily consider the impact upon the rights of other individuals in order to determine whether such a…