StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

The Nazi Doctors - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
The Nazi Doctors

In fact, they had a task of eliminating people that were considered unfit for work, while others were sacrificed for others to live. Therefore, this period entails complications regarding rules that were altered frequently in accordance with camp commandants. Nevertheless, the paper will focus on analysing this issue based on the idea whether the famous philosophers, Aristotle, Kant, and Mill would agree with the practices in which Nazi doctors were involved. Aristotle, Kant, and Mill do not agree with practices conducted by the Nazi doctors through the agreement of their medical professional. In this case, they were chosen to take role of concentrating camp doctor and saving lives of numerous people while making decision regarding condemning others to death. On the other hand, both Aristotle and Mill would support the argument that the Nazi were not in a position to decline the offer of position offered by the Nazi regime. In fact, the doctors were bound to admit these offers as a way of saving their own lives. Others agreed with the notion that they would increase the possibility of benefiting numerous people. As a utilitarian, Mill has a conviction that actions are considered right based on their aspect of promoting happiness while wrong leads to grief or unhappiness ((Mill, 2010). Therefore, causing death for innocent people created a difficulty, thus failing to comply with the Greatest Happiness Principle. Moreover, Aristotle sought to offer a better notion to support this idea, whereby indicating that wise people are able to bare kinds of fortune in a seemly way thereby acting in an aristocrats way in various situations (Amemiya, 2007). However, Kant disagrees with the idea of doctors agreeing to the mandates given to them by the Nazi regime. This is due to his maxims conviction, which is universalized without inconsistency (Cahn, 2012), whereby if it prevailed; the doctors would not have had a chance to make their Faustian bargain. Moreover, Kant (1964) argued that a man’s dignity is lost by lying; thus, decisions, which concern determining, people who will live or die does not require to be accommodated in the law or universalized maxims. In this case, the three philosophers were advocating for a world that facilitated coexistence whereby every human being lives without being subjected to death that would be caused by another human being. Difficult choices regarding establishment of a substantial number of choices was made by Aristotle and Mill, whereby they stood for consequentialism. In this case, there was not chance for Kant to establish a philosophical justification of the murder for some people for the sake of saving others. In fact, he advocates for deontological ethics that focuses on people’s intentions (Honderich, 2005). Therefore, Kant’s convictions do not support the killings perpetrated by Nazi doctors despite the idea of saving other people’s lives. Furthermore, this is an attitude, which can be supported through a verse in the Bible at Matthew 7:12, “Therefore all things whatsoever ye would that men should do to you, do you even so to them.” Concerning the choice of whether I would support the actions of Nazi doctors or the offer that was presented to them by the Nazi regime is a problem that required deep thinking. However, the analysis on the three philoso ...Show more


The Nazi Doctors Name: Tutor: Course: Institution: Date: The Nazi Doctors Decisions made between life and death that regard numerous innocent men, women and children, and this regard to anyone in either dying due illness or healthy. In fact, this is a situation can occur to anyone just like the situation that is subjected to numerous medical professionals…
Author : leone44
The Nazi Doctors essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"The Nazi Doctors"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Doctors from Hell by Vivien Spitz
The pages of human history are soaked in bloodshed related to various types of atrocities and heinous acts by man against the man, but the Nazi atrocities are without a parallel. Perhaps the entire state apparatus of all the categories, takes part in the operation of annihilation of Jews and some other communities, the leading part being that of politicians and the medical practitioners.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
In the early 20th century eugenics thrived as a popular belief system to the point that over 30 states had eugenic programs of sterilization in the United States (Joseph 342). More horrific adaptations of eugenics occurred in Hitler’s Germany.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Science and Nazi attitudes to race
What Role Did Science Play In Nazi Attitudes To Race? When Nazi Germany is mentioned, what comes to one’s mind are the Second World War and the Holocaust. The Holocaust brings to mind the murder of six million Jews and people of other races. What many fail to understand is how the Nazi’s comfortably massacred millions of people, merely because they belonged to a different human race.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
American companies in Nazi Germany
American companies in Nazi Germany Name Professor Course Date Introduction; Organising a government democratic or dictatorial is a very tasking job. There is a lot of data to sift through in the process of governance including, birth records to trace ancestry, census documentation and other official planning documents.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
The role of the Nazi medical professionals in the Holocaust
What made these people abandon there whole professional attitude What was the aim Could it happen again In the film Hannah and Sisters, directed by Woody Allen, one of the characters, an old Jewish artist, states that the question that should be asked regarding the Holocaust is not, "how could it happen" but rather" why does it not happen more often" This attitude expresses the idea that it is the Freudian sense of the id that dominates human nature.
30 pages (7500 words) Essay
The influence of the neo-nazi party in modern america
One such ideology is Neo-Nazism. Neo-Nazism is used to define the movements, which are social or political in nature and aim to rekindle the ideology of Nazism. The first Neo-Nazi party to be established in America
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Doctors from Hell by Vivien Spitz
Perhaps the entire state apparatus of all the categories, takes part in the operation of annihilation of Jews and some other communities, the leading part being that of politicians and the medical practitioners. Not a whimper of protest is raised by the doctors
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
History and Literature
zing the Jews, by depicting them as an inferior race, so as to enhance widespread anti-Semitism, and lay a foundation for eliminating the Jews’ freedoms and rights. The Nazis advocated for the exclusion of Jews from society used the media, schools and other art forms such as
2 pages (500 words) Essay
The main goal of these groups included organizing surprising and breaking out if the ghetto as well as joining partisan units that were against the German rule. Although these units were in full
1 pages (250 words) Essay
How German Conservative helped the Nazi Party to come to power
A few liberal thinkers directly inclined towards German conservatism would have believed that Nazi Party, emerging as a result of military soldiers’ unemployment, would have become the legitimately elected government of Germany by 1933. The German Conservative helped the Nazi Party to come to power through the following ways.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Contact Us