Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!

philospohy - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare
Author : deckowzena

Summary

Explain how Dretske responds to Chisholm's claim that intentionality cannot be naturalized. Do you think that Dretske's response is successful? Defend your answer. (Name) (Institution) (Course) (Tutor) (Date) Explain how Dretske responds to Chisholm's claim that intentionality cannot be naturalized…

Extract of sample
philospohy

It was the philosopher Fred Dretske who took to investigating the various claim that were made by the late Roderick Chisholm who postulated that intentional states could only possibly be mental states. In making this claim, Chisholm was seen to derive the claim mainly based on the thesis proposed by Franz Brentano the nineteenth century philosopher in his book “Psychology from an Empirical Standpoint”. This paper will attempt to evaluate the responses made by Dretske as pertains to Chisholm’s claims and determine their success. Chisholm’s Claim that Intentionality cannot be naturalized and Dretske’s Response to the Claim A key feature of various mental states is their actual content. An example being that in the event that I essentially believe it will snow, my actual belief as at the moment can be seen to represent a state of the weather and when I chance to see a dog, I become perpetually aware of that cat. My innate belief that it is eventually going to rain may be seen to be inaccurate or accurate, my perception as to the existence of the cat may be imprecise or precise and my desire to be loved my eventually be satisfied or unsatisfied. Brentano postulated that intentional states were essentially solely mental states and thus distinguished mental states from the physical states because they are objects of awareness and non-spatial in nature. ...
Download paper

Related Essays

Defining Philosophy Essay
While this definition provides a general understanding of philosophy, it is necessary to consider philosophy’s evolution in terms of schools of thought to properly encapsulate its essence. In these regards, it is perhaps most appropriate to start with ancient Greek philosophy, as it is here that the term philos (knowledge) first emerged. Within Greek philosophy there emerged three major schools – pre-Socratic, the middle period, and finally the Hellenistic era. Among these the most significant era was the middle period where texts by Plato and Aristotle functioned to investigate many of…
3 pages (753 words)
Analytical Essay 2
Plotinus and his apprentice Porphyry get credited as the founders of Neo-Platonism. This paper will compare and contrast the characterization of God in the summa theologica and the neo-Platonist view. Both the summa theologica and neo-Platonism account for the existence of a superior being or God. In the summa theological, Aquinas advances arguments that seek to establish and prove God’s existence (Brian 22). Aquinas states that there is a God simply because the world itself needs him as an explanation. The first part of the summa theologica concludes by Aquinas quipping that God cannot fail…
6 pages (1506 words)
Essay
Hence, a modern definition of democracy was established to distinguish it from other forms of government which were not people-centered. The contemporary definition of democracy is: “form of government, where a constitution guarantees basic personal and political rights, fair and free elections, and independent courts of law” (Democracy Building: para.7). This essay discusses how democracy has been viewed from different perspectives by prominent philosophers over the course of history. It attempts to merge their ideas while I as the author give my own views in reaction to their…
6 pages (1506 words)
Kant essay
Time was of the essence as the woman’s condition continued to deteriorate despite the application of certain remedial measures. According to standard practice, the doctors required the assent of the next of kin in order to perform the dangerous experiment. After several futile attempts to contact the family members, the doctors decided to proceed with the abortion with the intention of rescuing the life of the mother. The operation went on successfully as the fetus was aborted. However, both the woman and her family members expressed their disappointment in the loss of the child and vowed to…
4 pages (1004 words)
essay
These concepts are a fundamental part of knowledge that share different meanings (Lawhead 1-80).Priori knowledge is a process of gathering knowledge by way of performing those activities that may relate to gathering information from the physical world. However, it has been argued that it does not involve any scientific methods or practical experiences in this system (Lawhead 1-80). Posteriori knowledge can be understood as a process of congregating knowledge which is attained by years of experience (Lawhead 1-80). This category of knowledge can be argued to develop over a period from a…
3 pages (753 words)
Essay
I will also discuss the issue of an average woman’s needs and if they set in contrast with the elitist radical movement which concentrates on furthering wrong ideas. Finally, I will examine one objection raised by Marilyn Friedman on the subject of modern feminist ideology to estimate the extent to which Sommer’s position on the same subject could be held viable. First issue raised by Sommers in her argument refers to how unfortunate is it that a false contrast is created between sexism and assimilation by radical feminists. This false contrast serves to prevail the misleading feeling as…
5 pages (1255 words)
Moral Essay
On the context of hurting others, Nagel presents a moralistically sensitive stance. He believes that the best way to understand what the other person is feeling is to actualize with the feelings of the other person. Hurting another person in itself is a subjective concept, according to Nagel. Just like the concept of good or bad, or morality or even laws, the issues of transgressing the rights of another person is a matter which may not affect many if they cannot relate to it. Many people do not even tend to realize even after they have undergone the process of making someone feel…
4 pages (1004 words)