StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu
  • Home
  • Subjects
  • Philosophy
  • Why does Mackie think we need an error theory Do you think he is right to believe that we need it

Why does Mackie think we need an error theory Do you think he is right to believe that we need it - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
Why does Mackie think we need an error theory Do you think he is right to believe that we need it

The error theory suggests that morals are not absolute, that what is morally right or wrong vary from one society to another. It is a theory that states that morals are judged, not by the universal moral norms, but according to the society within which a circumstance calls for moral clarification (Dorsey 2006, p.495). When one considers the definition above, it can be stated that the morals are no longer absolute in different societies because of the fact that they have evolved over a long period, changing considerably from one society to another. A good number of the proponents of this theory, such as John Mackie, believe that morality was an invention of societies to maintain control over its members, and it is because of this that morality varies. If, for instance, morals and social norms were universal in all the societies, in the world, then there would have been no differences in morals, and as a result, the error theory would not have been developed. The error theory states that the idea of morality or the adherence to morals depends on the assumption that they exist; this assumption being false because morals are not based on the reality of the situations being judged. Error theory can be considered a viewpoint where there is the belief that morality is dependent on the norms of the cultures, which practice it. It is these societies which determine whether the actions of individuals is morally right or wrong and those who propagate this theory believe that there is nothing that can be said to be the absolute truth concerning morality because what is considered to be right in one society may not be considered the same in another. If one were to consider Mackie’s statements concerning the error theory, the fact that what is considered morally right in one society may not be so in another show that morality is not a universal norm. There are often chances where what is considered morally right in one culture may be considered wrong in another, an example being the situation of homosexuality. While, in the western world, homosexuality is an accepted norm in society, in other parts of the world, especially in Africa and Middle East, one would find that this practice is frowned upon, and those found in the act tend to be severely punished. Therefore, when it comes to the concept of the error theory, the opinion of what is right or wrong is not judged by norms that would be considered universal because of the fact that it cannot be measured nor do the said morals exist (Delapp 2009, p.8). Morals, if one were to follow Mackie’s argument, are made up by the societies, which put them in force and because of this, these societies become slaves to concepts, which are logically nonexistent. Among the main advantages of using the error theory when considering morals is the fact that a broad range of views concerning morals is taken into consideration. Since there is a wide variety of cultures and practices, it is easier for one to adapt to any situation that one may encounter through the understanding of the motivations behind the development of various cultural norms as well as look upon such morals in an objective way. Moreover, it can be said that the error theory can be used towards the development cultural understanding, which ensures that people are judged, not according to the opinions of other cultures, but according to that of their own cultures and societies. It recognizes that fact that morals are nonexistent and this creates a situation where societies can be studied on an equal footing. Since it is the society which judges what is right or wrong, the people within it have a clear understanding of what is ...Show more

Summary

The error theory states that the idea of morals is not absolute and that in fact, morals are only a figment of the imagination of the societies that practice them, since they are nonexistent. The error theory is a denial of the existence of morals and it can be said that the existence of morals is considered by the proponents of this theory to be relative to the society that practice them…
Author : werner85
Why does Mackie think we need an error theory Do you think he is right to believe that we need it essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Why does Mackie think we need an error theory Do you think he is right to believe that we need it"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Diary for one class-------- I will upload every think that you will need. You have to read the slides when it is need it and you
Likewise, Maria has also challenges when it comes to health reproductive concerns. First, she is very vulnerable to HIV as caused by her husband’s activities while being away. In addition to that, she is not well-informed about birth control .Second, she has developed aversion towards the clinic because of the attitude by the staff and her mother-in-law’s influence on traditional healing.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
How Do We Know What We Think We Know
The workday is filled with tidbits of news information floating in - gossip, posts on Facebook pages, televisions playing in the lunchtime restaurant, more email, or perhaps relevant news to your company is posted on the company home page. The ride home is much like the ride to work followed by an evening of sit-coms, news breaks, and perhaps a nightly dose of Jon Stewart or Stephan Colbert.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Do we still need library
Librarians are continually faced with the uphill task of redefining their position, rethinking the modes of service delivery, designing new models for librarianship and strategizing their futures. However, they have the opportunity of gaining a better understanding of their users and as such, more is expected from them compared to librarians in the past.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
The Nature of Theory Why we need to be able to think in theoretical terms
Basically, theories have lead to the different advancements that the world of human civilizations began to enjoy from then until now. However, it could be noticed how much only a few people are able to provide such theoretical understanding of such matters.
6 pages (1500 words) Assignment
Do we need to believe in a God or does God need us to exist
Conversely, if God hadn't been invented, would He have been necessary Professor Davies, a widely-acclaimed authority on Quantum Physics notes that people seek religion, not only for moral guidance, but also for answers to the fundamental questions of existence.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Incorporate Kierkegaard's observations on becoming a subject into your essay by way of evaluation: what do you think of Kierkegaard's response that we may only live in truth by becoming a subject What does he mean by tha
In evaluating, Kierkegaards response that we may only live in truth by "becoming a subject", we will need to define the dominant theme, pragmatism. It refers to a belief that human ideas carry some meaning or truth if and only if they
2 pages (500 words) Essay
What is Money and Why Do We Need It
Example: in a society where money is not involved a farmer produced wheat. He also needs salt. Salt producer wishes to acquire fish but not wheat. Hence the farmer would have firstly exchanged his wheat for fish and then
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
How does ideology shape the way we think
Dominant ideologies are those that are accepted collectively by the populations of entire cultures and societies. They shape people’s ways of reflecting about the world and its populations.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Do we think for ourselves or does society determine what we think (the social construction of reality)
Most sources on the paper have been found to be journals handling various case studies in America and also in Europe. They however, cover most of the basic areas in how social construction has affected the line of thought of many people. The paper will uncover
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Discuss how you think we should approach globalization
This paper presents a discussion of how we should approach globalization and whether corporations should take the lead in attempting to combat the negative effects of globalization, such
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment