In the realm of policy-making, a number of scholars1 in recent years have re-opened the doors towards understanding the role of ideas in policy change. Building upon the inadequacies of rational choice and institutional approaches, these theories emphasise that ideas play an important role in contributing to policy change…
Thus, this essay will argue that ideas affect policy change only indirectly, as paradigms frames and determinants of interest, such that its importance in understanding policy change is only secondary to other approaches.
To better understand the importance of a study of ideas in policy change, it is first necessary to understand what ideas are. Ideas are shared beliefs held by individuals. However, a distinction must be made between two categories of shared beliefs, particularly "consensual beliefs" and "economic ideas", where although not mutually exclusive differ in their relation to policy. As Jacobsen explains, the difference lies between those of "means" to "ends", where consensual beliefs "shape the legitimate ends of economic activity"; economic ideas are the means to reach these ends. 3 Taking this definition of ideas, the importance of a study of ideas in policy change can be summarised in their roles as paradigms, roadmaps, or ideational frames.
Comparing policy change to scientific revolutions, Hall (1989) places emphasis on the role of ideas through "policy paradigms", or "roadmaps" as Goldstein and Keohane (1993) calls them, where ideas guide policies by determining the "tracks" of policymaking and setting constraints in the policy process4. As Hall argues, policy paradigms, determine policy change in acting as "a framework that specifies the goals of policy and the kind of instruments that can be used to attain them", as well as the "nature of the problems they are meant to be addressing."5 Campbell's (1998) and Beland's (2005) ideational frames or programmes also echoes Hall's concept of paradigms, varying only in the manner that ideas are presented and implemented in the policy process. Within this strand of literature, the failures of policies to achieve economic goals are seen as the impetus for policymakers to search for alternative ideas that pave the way for new policy paradigms to be accepted. Hence, in times of uncertainty marked with "exogenous shocks, demographic changes [or] the perception of failed policy", new ideas emerge as either roadmaps or focal points that reduce uncertainty and provide alternatives.6 The policy shift during the first Thatcher government can therefore be explained as the result of a shift in policy paradigms; replacing Keynesian ideas with monetarist ideas (Hall, 1993).
Looking at the first Thatcher government, it is evident that the policy shift coincided with an ideational shift from Keynesian to monetarist where Keynesian policies were perceived to have failed in resolving rising inflation (Walsh, 2000). In this respect, ...
Cite this document
(“Policy Change Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.net/politics/282241-policy-change
(Policy Change Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
“Policy Change Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.net/politics/282241-policy-change.
The interest rate on 10 year Italian bond has increased to 6.6 % and the analysts have warned that its yields were now approaching the danger zone where a bail out can prove to be a risk. The crisis has been exacerbated by a sharp fall in the stock markets in Europe and it is suggested that an attempt to bail Italy will be challenging given that it is relatively big in size.
The researcher of this study aims to pay special attention to the two approaches - behaviour change and policy change approaches to mental health promotion in terms of how they fit into a general health promotion model. An in-depth reflection on the course and this study will then be undertaken, followed by a conclusion.
To this effect, nurses and their professional and welfare organizations should strategize to work with and incorporate politicians and political organization in their activities. There are several rules and legislations that politicians enact that have direct and indirect impact on nurses and patients, making the corporation among these stakeholders rather important.
Solstice Sleep Products (SSP) that deals with mattress products is one of the emerging companies in this field. With utmost focus on customer service and quality, this company continues to struggle to sustain its position and business due to various issues that are presently affecting its smooth running.
Since global warming has a potential impact of increasing the normal temperature it produces a lot of harmful effects for the people living on the earth. In order to restrict the emission of such gases two different forms of providing a deterrent feature is being discussed by the economists and other expert environmentalists; one is the Carbon tax and the other Emission trading.
The nature of the disease with its wide ranging forms and treatments makes it difficult to attack it on a single front. Research funding is allotted based on perceived need, available resources, and politics. Organizations, both public and private, fight for scarce
The population of the Russian empire overwhelmingly increased in the rural areas contributing over 85% of the entire population. The remaining 15% got absorbed in urban based industries. Agriculture acted as the main sector of the economy in the Tsarist Empire. The two
There are some arguments presented by Legro on the major strategic turning points in the United States. He highlighted collective ideas within states on how the outside world could be related to the United States.
Secondly, it was believed that developed countries should take deliberate actions to mitigate on the increase of the harmful effects of greenhouse-effects. Lastly, the developed countries should support
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
GOT A TRICKY QUESTION? RECEIVE AN ANSWER FROM STUDENTS LIKE YOU!
Let us find you another Essay on topic Policy Change for FREE!