StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Welfare States And Their Classification - Book Report/Review Example

Extract of sample
Welfare States And Their Classification

However, not only has the popularity of Esping-Andersen's work been under attack, other experts in this area of study have also closely scrutinized the viability of Andersen's controversial categorization which has provoked criticisms from different sectors of society including economists and feminists. This paper will carefully examine Esping-Andersen's welfare state models and the criticisms afforded to them and evaluate the feasibility of these classifications especially the social democratic model towards which Esping-Andersen has revealed his proclivity.

In his book, "Three Worlds of Capitalism," Esping-Andersen put forth the foundational dimensions of capitalist welfare states as viable 'systems of stratification' (1990: 69-77) which comprise of three dimensions: Social democratic, liberal and conservative. The social democratic model measures universality of public welfare entitlements, frees citizens from their reliance on the market and 'decommodifies' labour. Esping-Andersen refers to the term 'decommodification' as the extraction of an individual from dependency on the market. This is founded on his contention that "social rights push back the frontiers of capitalist power" (Esping-Andersen 1990: 16). The liberal model of welfare states, the second model, allows the market to be the prime mover of income distribution. In this classification, the 'state encourages the market' - and the decommodification of labour through welfare benefits is controlled to a minimum (Esping-Andersen 1990: 26-27). On the other hand, the conservative categorization is an 'undecided regime' (Manow 2004) as it embraces some aspects of the social democratic categorisation but mainly considers the status of the individual as the major basis of welfare entitlement. Esping-Andersen considers this regime unfavourable as it maintains inequality in the society and limits the liberalising prospects of the welfare state to decommodify its citizens especially its labour force (Manow 2004).
The substance of Esping-Andersen's classification is founded on the assertion that the theoretical models of the welfare state are insufficient and fail to adapt with the world's changing conditions. He opines that past research heavily depended on state expenditure as an indicator to measure the viability of the state welfare program. The assumption of experts rested firmly on the idea that spending and industrialisation could define a welfare state. Esping-Andersen, however, believes that this presumption is insufficient as solely considering this aspect of the welfare state cannot be understood through the measurement of levels of expenditure. He asserts that expenditures are minor corollary of the theoretical framework of the welfare system. Hence, broader variables must be introduced (Esping-Andersen 1990:19). He adds that the emphasis on spending is deceptive as it assumes that the state's expenditures on various welfare programs will have positive outcome. On the contrary, however, we can observe states which allocate much of their expenditure to payment of government welfare workers and the privileged class while in other nations budget on welfare programs is allotted to social support. Not many policymakers would deem this as acceptable welfare state policy (Esping-Andersen: 1990:19-20). On the contrary, Esping-Andersen contends that social rights, stratification and state-market connection are the characteristics that welfare states should be founded upon. He asserts that social rights hold the most dynamic potential for the decommodifica ...Show more


The study of welfare states and their classification within the last twenty years has been dominated by Gsta Esping-Andersen whose work, "The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism," influenced much of the welfare policies in the economically powerful Europe…
Author : agleichner
Welfare States And Their Classification essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the book report/review on your topic
"Welfare States And Their Classification"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Child Welfare Reform
To demonstrate the ineffectiveness of the Child welfare program, the author contends that 16 states in the country did not fulfill any of the seven federal childcare standards used to evaluate the efficiency of the program in the previous year. The author presents statistical data indicating that the rate of child abuse in the country increased in 2003 compared to 1990, mainly because of the government failure to enforce effective childcare policies in the country (Price 354).
2 pages (500 words) Book Report/Review
Government's Welfare Reform and Disabled People
It is these individuals that will fall through the cracks and be left out in the cold, as they will be considered hard to help clamance. They may be deemed unable to receive benefits, since they may not pass the new test that has been devised to see who can and cannot qualify because during the time they are tested, they may be feeling fine, which is not an accurate basis for determining whether or not they should be allowed to receive benefits.
13 pages (3250 words) Book Report/Review
Social Welfare in China
He proposed the concept of "invisible hand" which says that there is not much need for the intervention of the government or any other authority in the smooth functioning of the market and the market would correct itself automatically with the help of a pure demand and supply logic.
2 pages (500 words) Book Report/Review
Mary Childers ''Welfare Brat''
While it seems obvious that success follows a good education, many people either fail to pay attention to this point or they simply lack opportunities to educate themselves. Indeed, people who live in families that are poverty-stricken with no opportunities to gain an education, have very tedious lives.
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Reforming The Welfare System. White Paper Published In December 2008
The government published a white paper in December of 2008 that talked about reforming the welfare system to place more burdens on vulnerable groups, such as carers, disabled, and the sick, who are trying to receive benefits (Lawson). Those who are receiving benefits and have been without a job for two or more years will be required to work fulltime, thus contributing to the community.
13 pages (3250 words) Book Report/Review
The Impact of Immigration on the British Labour Market
The article provides a theoretical discussion about the nature of long run wage and employment effects of immigration under types of economies which differ in their flexibility to adapt immigration through changes in the that economy's output mix as well as on the degree of openness of the goods sector to trade and ultimately, to the extent output prices are determined locally or on the world markets.
8 pages (2000 words) Book Report/Review
Marxist Critiques of Welfare
Marx was very critical about the idea of capitalism. Marx was always looking for ways to decrease the support that was being given by the time's intellectuals to the idea of capitalism. By decreasing the intellectual support that capitalism was getting from the capitalists, the people could be made aware of the idea of the socialist era (Fergusson 88).
6 pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review
Oil and the GCC States
These changes have shed light to them as their status as rent states, which pertains to their significance as oil producers makes them rich by developed countries standard. The changes that are currently
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Self-Classification & Emerging Adulthood
30). The people falling in this category are often characterized by the desire to be self reliant physically, socially and financially. They require freedom to make their own choices especially in relation to occupation, character and also experimenting on issues like
1 pages (250 words) Book Report/Review
The Social Construction of a Welfare Mother
The research paper has three assumptions. The first hypotheses states that those who receive the welfare knows the stigma associated with them, and they understand the basic tenets of these views. The second theory
4 pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Contact Us