StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

A Real Divide Between the Law and Ethics - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper presents a brief discussion of some of the ethical theories will be undertaken. Virtue ethics works on the supposition that virtue is a habit of the soul. It is not just one a shot deal but it is a disposition towards the good that is developed as one lives life…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.5% of users find it useful
A Real Divide Between the Law and Ethics
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "A Real Divide Between the Law and Ethics"

?TO TELL OR NOT TO TELL INTRODUCTION Since the ancient period, humanity has already been asking the question ‘What should I do?’ when confronted withthe quandary between right or wrong, good or bad. As such, it is not surprising to find proffered approaches and possible answers for this query. However, have we really gone far in addressing this ‘seeming simple ‘question? Looking at the contemporary human condition, people are still struggling with the question. Despite the fact, theories and experiences have served as a guide in untangling the predicament, still, people find themselves perplex in the face of the dilemma between right and wrong. As with this case, Sunny who is a department head finds himself in the middle of an ethical dilemma. They are about to launch a new power crunch for kids. Considering the problem of obesity among children, it is a good strategy to include in the packing the phrase “100% less value added sugar”. In fact, in a study conducted, there is a possibility of increasing sales up to 22. 45% based on this strategy alone. However, Sunny is not comfortable with the scenario even if the product that they will launch is indeed 100%less value sugar. This is because to compensate for the decrease in sugar, they have increase the carbohydrate content of the krunch. Thus, in effect the product does not offer any weight loss advantage. What must Sunny do, to tell or not to tell? THE THEORIES When dealing with the question of right or wrong, one enters the field of Ethics. As noted, ethics is different with morality in terms of ethics, although pertaining to the question of rightness or wrongness of an act, is addressed base on the systems and theories raise by philosophers and secular thinker. Whereas, morality, also addressing the same question, refers to the different approaches that religion, society, and institutions have come up with (Plenary 3, Lecture Notes). Ethics has given several theories such as deontology, teleology, virtue ethics, utilitarianism and many more. For this section, a brief discussion of some of the ethical theories will be undertaken. Virtue ethics works on the supposition that virtue is a habit of the soul. It is not just one a shot deal but it is a disposition towards the good that is developed as one lives life (Doris, 1998). In this regard, virtue ethics deals not only with the question of the rightness or wrongness of the act at a certain situation but it primarily looks into the character of the human person - the agent. Thus, in virtue ethics, it is presupposed that having a good character will enable one to make the right decision at all times, especially, during dire situations. It holds consistency in human character – good character. However, virtue ethics does not really provide clear cut criteria for the rightness or wrongness of an act but, it can tell you whether the person is good or bad depending on behavioural manifestations. Moreover, virtue ethics does not address the problem of relativism – one good trait may not be considered as good in another culture. Another theory is utilitarianism. In this theory, the rightness or wrongness of the act is dependent on the entailed consequences of the act (Velasquez, 2006). If there will be many beneficiaries from the act, then the act is good. In other words, if the act will make more people happy, then the act is good. In this sense, as focus is turned on the consequence of the act, counting how many will be happier or how many will benefit from the act becomes the parameter for the rightness or wrongness of the act. This theory is criticised because it is vague as to what is happiness and on how happiness will be measured. Moreover, question of relativism and the danger of the fallacy of the majority become an inherent concern of this theory. Duty-based ethics is the last theory that will be briefly discussed. According to this theory, rightness or wrongness of the act does not depend on its consequence, rather, rightness or wrongness is inherent in the act itself. As such, there are acts that one ought to do and acts which one ought not to do. This theory provides a straightforward directive on what ought to be done. This is because the theory rests on the assumption that all human beings are rational human agent and as rational agents they will do the right act and avoid the wrong one (Gardner, 2006). However, the certainty of the theory brings into light one of the criticisms raise against duty-based ethics – it fails to recognise the significance of the context from which the dilemma arises. It puts too much trust on the rational human agent that it will follow the dictate of reason. Likewise, it does not provide a definitive solution in the face of conflicting duties. These theories are intended to guide our decision in taking the right act in the midst of an ethical dilemma. However, how? MY POSITION As somebody coming from the legal profession, sometimes I think that question of ethics is not within the purview of the law. In fact, it is claimed that as the law provides certitude, and a clear black and white dichotomy, ethics on the other hand is a grey area(Crane & Matten, 2007).. For instance, Report on the Law Relating to Dishonesty provides a clear guide as to how people in the legal system will understand the legal notion of dishonesty. Moreover, it lays down several possible cases wherein dishonesty is perceptible such offenses relating to computers, fraud between husband and wife, deception and many more (see [1992] IELRC 2). This is the case since, “The rule of law requires that rights and duties under the law are determined” ([1999] EWCA Civ 1144). Thus, it appears to be easy to fall back to question of law rather than to the value question of right or wrong. However, I think I am making things very simplistic. The easy stuff is only possible if there is a real divide between the law and ethics. Unfortunately, it is not. The neutral party, is perceived as the common stance of those in the legal profession, does not provide guidance for ethical decision. Law and lawyers are not removed from the ethical questions arising in living in the real world. Going back in the case of Sunny, I’ll be suggesting that they use a different approach in promoting the krunch. As “A company cannot be injured in its feelings, it can only be injured in its pocket. ...The injury need not necessarily be confined to loss of income. Its goodwill may be injured” ([1964] A.C. 234). This being said, I suggest that they highlight other attributes of the product that will distinguish it from other similar products in the market. In this way, the dilemma can be avoided. Sometimes I think that we tend to limit ourselves into just right or wrong, good or bad, when in fact there are other approaches that maybe used. Ethics teaches this. There are always several approaches that can be used and in opting one over the other, it affirms our being rational and our goal in creating a more humane society for everyone. REFERENCES Crane, A & Matten, D 2007 Business Ethics, second Edition, New York: Oxford University Press, Doris, J M 1998 Persons, situations and virtue ethics, Nous, vol. 32, no 4, pp. 504 – 530. Gardner, S 2006 The Primacy of practical reason. In Graham Bird (ed) A Companion to Kant, London: A Blackwell Publishing Ltd. Plenary 3 An ethical balloon debate. Lecture Notes. Velasquez, MG, 2006, Business Ethics: Concepts and Cases, Sixth Edition, New York: Pearson. CASES Report on the Law Relating to Dishonesty [1992] IELRC 2 Steel & Anor v McDonald’s Corporation & Anor [1999]EWCA Civ 1144 Lewis v. Daily Telegraph Ltd. [1964] A.C. 234 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A Real Divide Between the Law and Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
A Real Divide Between the Law and Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1407392-law-essay-compare-and-contrast-the-use-of-three
(A Real Divide Between the Law and Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
A Real Divide Between the Law and Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1407392-law-essay-compare-and-contrast-the-use-of-three.
“A Real Divide Between the Law and Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1407392-law-essay-compare-and-contrast-the-use-of-three.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Real Divide Between the Law and Ethics

Ethical Theories: Description And Application

These theories include Deontology and Utilitarianism, as well as the moral theory of David Hume, which is a type of virtue ethics.... Consequentialism is a system of ethics where the moral statuses of actions are based on their consequences, rather than on the actions themselves.... Deontological systems of ethics are often explained in contrast to consequentialist ones, because they are essentially the opposite.... See whether a world is even conceivable, where every person must complete that action, and if it is, whether you would rationally will that it become a universal law....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Kierkegaards Philosophical Viewpoints on Ethics and Critics of his Work

Abraham here finds himself in contradiction; he has to decide between the will of God and his beloved son.... ethics derives from the Greek word "ethikos" and defines the "living theory", the right or wrong in sense of morality.... hellip; ethics is divided into three main categories; Metaethics, Normative ethics, and Applied Ethics1.... The first deals with the origin of our ethical convictions, the involvement of the divine element in our ethical perceptions and how it affects our ethics....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Ethical Dillemmas and Decision Making Processes

ethics is the branch of philosophy that inquires into the normative and moral evaluation of human actions.... Normative ethical systems have been classified into three categories: deontological, teleological and virtue ethics.... Let us look at these three systems of ethics in some detail.... Kant's ideology follows a model of deontological or duty-based ethics.... mmanuel Kant put forth the rational principle of 'categorical imperative' of which the following two formulations are extremely well-known and captures his idea brilliantly: “Always act in such a way that you can also will that the maxim of your action should become a universal law”, “Act so that you treat humanity, both in your own person and in that of another, always as an end and never merely as a means”....
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework

Real and Personal Property

Instead, this matter is usually all embracing when certain persons need to have their rights to chattels or land respected and enforced by the law.... It is essential for one to acquire property legitimately in accordance to the law so as to seek its protection.... Other law dictionaries continue to add that property is the exclusive right of certain individuals to possess, Property is usually divided into two aspects; the first being the personal property and the second is real property....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Ethical Leadership Description

Van Wart (2008) described another important model of ethical leadership called the ethics-based approach causal chain which posits that “leadership styles grounded on social consciousness, self-discipline and courage [are directed towards] performance goals for the greatest common good, empowerment of followers and quality of decision; [and the realization of these goals are influenced by] … the consciousness of ethical responsibilities, self-discipline and the courage of conviction” (p....
4 Pages (1000 words) Annotated Bibliography

Technology, Business and Ethics

 The paper "Technology, Business and ethics identifies one current issue that presents an ethical problem for an organization, describes the context of the problem, explains why it is a problem (using relevant theories from the course) and explains what should be done about it.... everal viewpoints can be taken in terms of how business ethics and ethics, in general, would respond to the use of this thought scanner.... Of course, depending on the situation of the company, some issues may carry a sense of urgency while others could be put on the back burner but it must be kept in mind that all ethics-related issues will need to be tackled sooner or later....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper

Relationship between Truth and Knowledge

hellip; In the simplest sense, mathematics deals with reality from an objective perspective, whereas arts and ethics view it from a subjective point.... But truth in arts and ethics is viewed from the artist's standard who produces the artwork.... However, there is no distinction between the facts of the hard and soft areas of philosophy and the non-fuzzy regions of mathematics and logic (Yuengert 5).... Not entirely separate from this debate is whether there are different kinds of reality, including the traditional philosophy at ethics, aesthetics, and mathematics....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Carbon Emission Trading and Business Ethics in British Airways

hellip; This paper intends to address the following questions: What are the inherent connections between the contemporary nature of the organization, carbon emission trading and business ethics?... The paper “Carbon Emission Trading and Business ethics in British Airways” gives a conceptual analysis of the interrelation of the holistic, synergistic and integrative British Airways' response to the global warming problem with company's carbon emission trading and business ethics....
34 Pages (8500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us