To try to understand individuals and the society, the paper will discuss the works of Emile Durkheim, Max Weber, and Thomas Hobbes who are the earliest founders of sociology. Emile Durkheim (1857-1917) His conception of society is based on realism which views society as an external reality existing outside of individuals and can be studied as such (Morrison 2006, p. 150). His theory therefore, is based on the idea that society exists before the individual, and that individuals are shaped by the structures and mechanisms of society. He (Durkheim) conceives the individual as acting in pursuit of his own interests but constrained by the social facts of society. In his study, he regarded individuals as members of a social system hence they are social actors who observe and interpret facts of the external world. The social facts in this case refer to language, religion, economy, and law and other beliefs and values that exist in society and determine the actions of individuals. He considered them as real and therefore referred to society as “Sui-generis” (Roberts 1997 ch.6, par 11) meaning the society is real. As observed by Morrison (2006, p. 152) Durkheim asserts that the external framework of the society is made up of structures and mechanisms that constitute realities and make individuals members of society. He gives an example of how the class structure determines the rank and position of individual in social hierarchy. According to him, these structures and mechanisms are objective and given at birth and possess power and dispositions that affect people’s actions by placing restrictions on them. Individuals as pursuits of own interests have senses, and therefore engage only in those activities that are beneficial to them. In the process of trying to achieve their goals, they exchange with other individuals in the society thus develop mutual relations and act in solidarity guided by what Durkheim refers as collective conscience. Solidarity and collective conscience unlike the society are not given. In his work, Durkheim stressed the importance of the role played by rules, values and beliefs and asserted that the authority of the society superseded that of an individual. In this case, the society is said to have a collective conscience as opposed to individual conscience. To live in harmony, social solidarity is vital and thus he recognised two kinds of social solidarity; the mechanical and organic solidarity. He also emphasised the role of division of labour in enhancing movement of individuals from mechanical to organic solidarity. As observed by Morrison (2006, pp. 160-165) Durkheim regarded mechanical solidarity as one that exists in primitive or traditional societies. Each traditional society has values and beliefs that become the norms which individuals must conform to and these form a code of ethics for the society. Deviation from the norm is considered pathological and a crime punishable by use of repressive laws. He (Durkheim) recognised the role played by religion in the integration of society as the provider of moral ground on which to judge individuals or the religious law. It thus becomes the moral duty and obligation to conform to moral authority. If an individual fails
Cite this document
(“How Do Hobbes,Weber and Durkheim Relate the Indivual to Society Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.net/sociology/62659-how-do-hobbesweber-and-durkheim-relate-the
(How Do Hobbes,Weber and Durkheim Relate the Indivual to Society Essay)
“How Do Hobbes,Weber and Durkheim Relate the Indivual to Society Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.net/sociology/62659-how-do-hobbesweber-and-durkheim-relate-the.
Cited: 0 times
Name of student: Topic: Lecturer: Date of Presentation: Relation of Individual to Society Sociologists have different perspectives regarding how society is formed and how the individual relates to the society. Some theorists such as Hobbes and Weber emphasise on individual as independent of society hence existing before formation of society while others like Durkheim emphasize on society as an external reality existing outside the individual…
As the report declares in the social theory point of view, he firstly defines a society as coming up with an institution that constitutes unequal power and dominion relations. Secondly, a society to him is structuring of social interactions in a social institution and again as process of converting linguistic structures into social interactions.
No one can have a doubt about the genius of Karl Marx whose theories were instrumental in lending social sciences the importance they are attached with today. He was among the first three sociologists (Weber and Durkheim being the other two) to throw light on the dynamic of the relationship between society and economy.
We focus on the bureaucratization theory, social fact theory, religion, a division of labour and specialization and the capitalist theory by Marx. All these theories explain the society we live in today but they also form a basis for determining whether the scholar's work is relevant in today’s society.
According to the report, Marx, Weber and Durkheim, more importantly, some of their conflicting ideas can be found similar in their original concept. Thus, Weber had several similar concepts to Marx, though they differed in many essential questions, and it is possible to compare Durkheim with both Marx and Weber.
re then there will be conflict in that particular society as people will be involved in practices that will not be in line with norms and rules of society. Karl Marx had his philosophy on dialectical materialism in that he claimed that in a society there were two groups that is
As such, society is real while for others individual is real. There is thus a lot of controversy as to whether society is shaped by individuals or it is the individuals who shape the society. Although,
In particular, his researches were based on investigating different manifestations of personal behavior in current social life. And so, prevalence of negative aspects in data set incited him to create the theory of human nature with
Scholars such as Emile Durkheim and Marx Weber spent their time doing research on religion and its social role in the society. According to Durkheim, religion is an expression of individuals’ collective consciousness and society and every society has its
6 pages (1500 words)Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you!Try us!
Let us find you another Essay on topic How Do Hobbes,Weber and Durkheim Relate the Indivual to Society for FREE!